Sully movie
#71
Banned
Joined APC: Feb 2016
Posts: 377
#72
I could not imagine having to fly a trip with you. You want to argue anything and everything with everyone. Nightmare
#74
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Nov 2009
Posts: 5,192
25 years ago to get on with a regional airline, you had to have thousands of hours and in many cases PAY $15,000 or so to get hired. Hiring minimums weren't an issue because no one could come close to TOUCHING a job at a regional without a couple of thousand hours. Then you would be flying a 19 seat turboprop for about $17,000 a year. (My first regional was $9,000 a year). More recently things got out of whack with some 300 hour pilots suddenly finding themselves in the right seat of a regional jet with an ever expanding number of seats. If you found a weak captain, let's say one that had failed 5-6 checkrides, and paired them with one of these inexperienced pilots, you could easily find yourself in a horrible situation. Buffalo. Not good. Experience isn't everything, but it is a critical component to safe operation.
Major airlines are not having trouble filling classes. Occasionally someone won't show up because they accepted another offer, but there are plenty of applicants for the airlines that pay well.
Type less, learn more. Pilots getting into the game now have it better than any group in a generation.
Last question. When you read an accident report, do you think "That moron! I would never do that??" For some perspective, whenever I read an accident report, I think "Man, pay close attention to this because I really don't ever want to do that". That's the best lesson my 16,000+ hours has taught me.
#75
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Jul 2013
Posts: 10,061
It wasn't a political knee jerk. If anything, the rest rules were the knee jerk. Neither of the pilots would have been illegal under the current rules. The Captain was a pay-to-play who spent from 250 hours with a wet commercial in the right seat of a large turboprop aircraft. When he was faxed with adversity, he did the exact opposite of what he was trained to do and part of it was his inexperience operating an aircraft under anything other than normal flight conditions.
#76
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Nov 2011
Position: A320 Capt
Posts: 5,293
No. I flew with him for a month.
I've flown with captains that were on par with him professionally, but not many that had the complete package of good airman, good captain and that carried himself as well as him. Hopefully the vast majority of us would have had as successful outcome, I doubt many could have pulled off the PR stuff as well.
#77
Banned
Joined APC: Feb 2016
Posts: 377
Of course it was. It had zero to do with the incident at hand. Were they sleep deprived and possibly not well trained? Yes. But both pilots were well above 1500TT
Over the long term, it does work out.
Over the long term, it does work out.
#78
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Aug 2007
Position: non acceptus excretus
Posts: 561
The concept of having more than 1500 TT BEFORE you begin with a scheduled point A to point B operator of a "carrying travelling public" situation is what you seem to not comprehend. There is a solidification of hands on flying skills that was missing in the accidents and incidents of the post 2000 regional industry. The "puppy mill pilots" are legend within the industry, as much as you advocate for them you only diminish your credibility on this forum. We have seen the good, the bad, and the ugly. The 1500 hour rule is inconvenient for you since you started your attempt at an airline career late in life. But the 1500 hour rule has ample justification or more likely mandate. You just don't like it because it is in your way. Get a CFI and instruct until you meet the 1500 hrs and you will be a better pilot than if you just went to the Gulfstream Academy and got the "puppy mill certificate"..And that goes for down the road when you have 5,000 + hours hours and have been at that regional or "real airline" for a while.m, Fortunately the "puppy mill option" no longer exists.
#79
What you don't seem to get is that airline flying doesn't build the basic foundational skill set every pilot requires. Those need to be well established before you ever set foot on the company property. You can't get them flying an airliner. Whatever you show up with is what you got. Your stick and rudder skills aren't going to magically improve when you spend most of the flight with the autopilot on and hand fly for a few minutes every other flight. Muscle memory and stick/rudder reflexes, cross-check, habit patterns, etc. all get ingrained as you gain experience prior to the airlines.
The Colgan captain didn't fire-wall his throttles and he pulled back on the yoke during a stall because he never had those skills in the first place. He probably would have done the same thing after another 5000 hours of mundane, autopilot airline flying. So, the fact that he had more than 1500 hours of flying when he crashed is irrelevant. How many hours he had and what his skills/experience was when he took that job in the first place is.
#80
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Jul 2013
Posts: 10,061
Total time at time of accident has almost literally nothing to with skill. Even the RAA argues that not all flying is created equal. It is vitally important to give yourself a chance to make mistakes. If you go from being with an instructor to being in the right seat of an airplane flying passengers, many argue that you never fully and adequately get to make mistakes, ones that scare you. The Asiana crew that put a 777 into the rocks at SFO had over ten thousand hours combined and yet one of the reasons why they crashed that airplane was partially because very few of those ten thousand hours was actually flying an airplane.
Last edited by CBreezy; 07-01-2016 at 06:29 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post