Pension vs Seniority
#21
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Mar 2007
Position: Petting Zoo
Posts: 2,068
To make this thread all about ME, let me throw a wrench in this topic and say the same guy was at 16yrs (4yrs from retirement) however, flying currently in his active job and would be when he hit 20yrs (but that's in 2019). Do you leave the mil retirement money on the table, walk for the QOL and seniority # now at 16years or stay to the 20yr point to collect from Uncle Sam?
[All of this assumes you get on with a Major at this 16yr point, do the reserve gig so you don't waste the 16yrs you have, etc.]
[All of this assumes you get on with a Major at this 16yr point, do the reserve gig so you don't waste the 16yrs you have, etc.]
To me the question is do you want to stay active or not for another 4 years.
I'm one of those guys who never meant to stay in. I'm extremely thankful for the pension and tricare.
If you look at retirement numbers, they are pretty impressive from 18 on.
Good luck.
#22
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Feb 2008
Posts: 19,226
Double check your numbers. Remember, your numbers are percentage based off the "High 3" (if I understand your timeline correctly, that's the retirement system you're under), i.e., an average of your highest 36 months of pay. If you're an O-5 for less than 36 months, you won't be getting X% of that, it'll be a blend of your O-4 & O-5 pay (further complicated by annual CoL raises). I don't know if you included that in your calculations, but your $1,000 / mo (or $800 / mo in your numbers above) estimate seems potentially high....
As others have said, only you can decide--but, one more opinion to add to the pile, take the retirement NOW, get hired ASAP, and enjoy the benefits of seniority sooner, both financially & QoL....
Good luck!
As others have said, only you can decide--but, one more opinion to add to the pile, take the retirement NOW, get hired ASAP, and enjoy the benefits of seniority sooner, both financially & QoL....
Good luck!
#23
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Mar 2008
Position: A-320
Posts: 1,122
To make this thread all about ME, let me throw a wrench in this topic and say the same guy was at 16yrs (4yrs from retirement) however, flying currently in his active job and would be when he hit 20yrs (but that's in 2019). Do you leave the mil retirement money on the table, walk for the QOL and seniority # now at 16years or stay to the 20yr point to collect from Uncle Sam?
[All of this assumes you get on with a Major at this 16yr point, do the reserve gig so you don't waste the 16yrs you have, etc.]
[All of this assumes you get on with a Major at this 16yr point, do the reserve gig so you don't waste the 16yrs you have, etc.]
For your situation create a spreadsheet with airline 401k starting in 2015 and have it grow at 16% contribution and at 6% growth. In another column calculate your mil pension starting in 4 years, include COLA and have it grow at 6%. Keep in mind the MIL money will not shrink as a 401k could and you get that money even if you have a medical issue. You could still get your 4 years in and be on the front side of the hiring boom. But also keep in mind the 4 years you miss at a major are 4 years less at the top of the pay scale.
#24
I know a lot of guys who did that in the 90's and regretted it after 9/11...guys old enough to be O-6's were coming back as O-3's so they'd have Tri-care and a few bucks a month after age 60 (the age 65 rule has since changed the dynamic a bit though). It worked out the airline crisis at the time coincided with a military build up.
Any way you can do light staff duty, drill free for points, correspondence courses just to keep it alive on the back burner?
I agree things look pretty rosy for the next 15-20 years, but you never know what can happen with this industry.
Any way you can do light staff duty, drill free for points, correspondence courses just to keep it alive on the back burner?
I agree things look pretty rosy for the next 15-20 years, but you never know what can happen with this industry.
#25
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Apr 2013
Posts: 523
I am walking away from the reserves at 15 years. Having to wait until age 60 to collect a check is the main reason.
For your situation create a spreadsheet with airline 401k starting in 2015 and have it grow at 16% contribution and at 6% growth. In another column calculate your mil pension starting in 4 years, include COLA and have it grow at 6%. Keep in mind the MIL money will not shrink as a 401k could and you get that money even if you have a medical issue. You could still get your 4 years in and be on the front side of the hiring boom. But also keep in mind the 4 years you miss at a major are 4 years less at the top of the pay scale.
For your situation create a spreadsheet with airline 401k starting in 2015 and have it grow at 16% contribution and at 6% growth. In another column calculate your mil pension starting in 4 years, include COLA and have it grow at 6%. Keep in mind the MIL money will not shrink as a 401k could and you get that money even if you have a medical issue. You could still get your 4 years in and be on the front side of the hiring boom. But also keep in mind the 4 years you miss at a major are 4 years less at the top of the pay scale.
#26
Line Holder
Thread Starter
Joined APC: Oct 2014
Posts: 46
Double check your numbers. Remember, your numbers are percentage based off the "High 3" (if I understand your timeline correctly, that's the retirement system you're under), i.e., an average of your highest 36 months of pay. If you're an O-5 for less than 36 months, you won't be getting X% of that, it'll be a blend of your O-4 & O-5 pay (further complicated by annual CoL raises). I don't know if you included that in your calculations, but your $1,000 / mo (or $800 / mo in your numbers above) estimate seems potentially high....
#27
Then there were 1 or 2 papers written by officers in ACSC and War College that addressed it in the 90's
I'm sure that Kit did address it: after 20 years of saying "hiring will pick up soon", it finally happened. I guess he was right.
#28
I have never flown a trip with another pilot who said "yeah..quitting the reserves was the right thing to. Glad I got out...." I HAVE flown with a bunch who have said "yeah...I'd have been retired from that gig years ago..." or "...I am enjoying these checks that just started showing up..." Staff, points only, or something...but don't give it all up. Time goes by faster and faster the older you get...
#30
We'll be grandfathered. Also I suspect all the talk of eliminating the 20-year system was intended more as a distraction so folks wouldn't pay as much attention to reforms in other benefits (like commissaries and medical).
The 20-year pension is inextricably linked to our current career-progression system and military culture. You'd upset the whole apple-cart if you just axed it...there would be unintended consequences. Somebody somewhere has to realize that.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post