Malaysian 777 missing
#1061
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Jun 2008
Posts: 3,716
#1062
Their premise: the pings stayed the same distance from a geosynchronous satellite over the Indian ocean.
But I wonder: how accurate? Plus or minus how much?
As the +/- tolerance gets bigger, the two arcs from last radar contact (based on the satellite) get wider.
If they get wide enough, they would merge, and literally the entire Indian Ocean is your search area.
DME tolerance is +/- 3%. Are satellite pings the same......or worse?
#1063
I have wondered the same thing.
Their premise: the pings stayed the same distance from a geosynchronous satellite over the Indian ocean.
But I wonder: how accurate? Plus or minus how much?
As the +/- tolerance gets bigger, the two arcs from last radar contact (based on the satellite) get wider.
If they get wide enough, they would merge, and literally the entire Indian Ocean is your search area.
DME tolerance is +/- 3%. Are satellite pings the same......or worse?
Their premise: the pings stayed the same distance from a geosynchronous satellite over the Indian ocean.
But I wonder: how accurate? Plus or minus how much?
As the +/- tolerance gets bigger, the two arcs from last radar contact (based on the satellite) get wider.
If they get wide enough, they would merge, and literally the entire Indian Ocean is your search area.
DME tolerance is +/- 3%. Are satellite pings the same......or worse?
The doppler motion analysis was not very good (they tried to look at the relativistic / motion shift of the pings to determine direction of travel.)
There was a really nice quite scientific article in aviation week IIRC a year ago or so, I'll try to dig it up and post if you are interested. It addressed those questions and more and was a great read.
#1064
The probem I have with this whole premise:
I see two scenarios: an incapacitated crew (likely, in my opinion), or a hijacking. (Unlikely, in my view).
For an incapacitated crew, if the controls of a 777 are released, IIRC, it rolls out and flies in a straight line.
If it were hijacked, it would take a lot of skill to fly it on an arc that just happens to stay a constant distance fom a satellite. Even if you knew the point over the Indian ocean that was the satellite's lcation, there is no way to do "turns about a point" using the navigation system....I think its maximum "arc" you can program is about 800 nm. I flew arcs in the military; airline pilots (and hijackers) generally do not, and wouldn't be very proficient at it.
If it were an incapacitated crew and it was on autopilot, same thing: it would follow the route programmed; same improbabilities as a hijacking.
Personally, I believe it flew in a straight line after crew incapacitation, and crashed near where they found the flaperon. Some minor thing has been overlooked in the satellite-ping theory that would prove it a red herring.
My theory, at least.
I see two scenarios: an incapacitated crew (likely, in my opinion), or a hijacking. (Unlikely, in my view).
For an incapacitated crew, if the controls of a 777 are released, IIRC, it rolls out and flies in a straight line.
If it were hijacked, it would take a lot of skill to fly it on an arc that just happens to stay a constant distance fom a satellite. Even if you knew the point over the Indian ocean that was the satellite's lcation, there is no way to do "turns about a point" using the navigation system....I think its maximum "arc" you can program is about 800 nm. I flew arcs in the military; airline pilots (and hijackers) generally do not, and wouldn't be very proficient at it.
If it were an incapacitated crew and it was on autopilot, same thing: it would follow the route programmed; same improbabilities as a hijacking.
Personally, I believe it flew in a straight line after crew incapacitation, and crashed near where they found the flaperon. Some minor thing has been overlooked in the satellite-ping theory that would prove it a red herring.
My theory, at least.
#1065
I came up with a (barely) plausible incapacitation theory involving fire and deliberate cabin pressure dumping to fight said fire. Hi alt environment extinguishes fire but also extinguishes crew and pax. FBW airplanes flies on...
But my theory requires some coincidences (no radio call, fire takes out certain avionics, etc).
Much as I prefer to give the crew the BOD, Ocams Razor says it was hijacked. Logic then says it was hijacked by a crew member, because the "usual suspects" or their like would have done something more dramatic than vanish if they were in control of a fully-fueled 777.
But my theory requires some coincidences (no radio call, fire takes out certain avionics, etc).
Much as I prefer to give the crew the BOD, Ocams Razor says it was hijacked. Logic then says it was hijacked by a crew member, because the "usual suspects" or their like would have done something more dramatic than vanish if they were in control of a fully-fueled 777.
#1066
In response to a few of the posts above, here is a summary of BTO characteristic:
http://www.atsb.gov.au/media/5187038...et_dec2014.pdf
There is a full technical document I remember reading somewhere but I can't find it right now, I'll search my HD to post if people interested. Basically it goes into math of the "cone intersecting a sphere" that gives the arc.
Now even if the arc was exactly right, and modeling the flight path from last known arc, there is additional sea drift components etc. It will be found, but may take a while!
http://www.atsb.gov.au/media/5187038...et_dec2014.pdf
There is a full technical document I remember reading somewhere but I can't find it right now, I'll search my HD to post if people interested. Basically it goes into math of the "cone intersecting a sphere" that gives the arc.
Now even if the arc was exactly right, and modeling the flight path from last known arc, there is additional sea drift components etc. It will be found, but may take a while!
#1067
New Hire
Joined APC: May 2015
Posts: 3
Here's today's latest theory... Crashed in the jungle.
MH370 plane wreckage claimed to be found on Philippine island | Daily Mail Online
MH370 plane wreckage claimed to be found on Philippine island | Daily Mail Online
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
bgmann
Foreign
25
01-30-2008 11:26 AM