I’m not trying to step on toes, Ivan......but I think when a CPP/AVIATE candidate fails the process, and then leaves for another carrier........doesn’t bother UAL in the slightest. They clearly decided against them for a reason (fair or unfair, not for me to speak on). More senior and mid-level pilots leave, and are replaced with cheaper new hires. I 100% understand your frustration, and I know you care about the pilots you represent. Your comment that the CPP was a “disaster” has a LOT to do with perspective. I consider it the best thing that ever happened to me, professionally. I know it wasn’t “fair”, but that’s ALSO a matter of perspective.