Always a matter of opinion and the devil is in the details. While the details have not been discussed the summary is another concessionary type of agreement for growth. Basically a reduction in work rules overall for wages that match ATI and very little increases to the future. What little remains is still above ATI in some rules but some are eroded to a level where they will catch up in the next round if not even exceed what the ABX proposed CBA is. Just look at the percentage of increase of the years of what has been publically posted on here...2%/yr for a long term agreement...yuk! (But it will pass a vote....)