Originally Posted by
250 or point 65
...
FURTHERMORE, I can take a private pilot up to show him a takeoff, pattern, and landing and HE can log PIC if he never touches the controls because Dual given as a private is PIC.
No. The private pilot must manipulate the controls to log the time as PIC. Dual given is not PIC time, just "dual given" in the instructor's logbook, and "dual received" in the students logbook. It has nothing to do with logging PIC time as stated in 61.51.