Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   American (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/american/)
-   -   Basic questions about QOL at AA (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/american/135801-basic-questions-about-qol-aa.html)

EMBFlyer 11-30-2021 01:19 PM


Originally Posted by TallFlyer (Post 3328999)
So, looking at the class drops, for someone who wants to get on the Bus, what are the Pros and Cons of LAX vs LGA as a new hire who’d be commuting?

I know that LGA means you’re covering JFK/LGA/EWR, and LAX I believe is LAX/SNA/SAN?

Ultimate goal is getting back to CLT, but my gut instinct is doing some West Coast / HI flying to start could be fun.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

LAX is 320/I. You can always do Out of Base Makeup (as a line holder) in CLT, which is also 320/I. LGA is only 320/D and you won't be International qualified (because it takes 3 days of training to learn to fly to Cancun). So keep that in mind. Also, for Mutual Base Exchange, it's a lot harder to do it cross-division.

TallFlyer 11-30-2021 03:43 PM


Originally Posted by EMBFlyer (Post 3329178)
LAX is 320/I. You can always do Out of Base Makeup (as a line holder) in CLT, which is also 320/I. LGA is only 320/D and you won't be International qualified (because it takes 3 days of training to learn to fly to Cancun). So keep that in mind. Also, for Mutual Base Exchange, it's a lot harder to do it cross-division.

I think you just cinched the deal for me.

FlyyGuyy 11-30-2021 04:11 PM


Originally Posted by EMBFlyer (Post 3329178)
LAX is 320/I. You can always do Out of Base Makeup (as a line holder) in CLT, which is also 320/I. LGA is only 320/D and you won't be International qualified (because it takes 3 days of training to learn to fly to Cancun). So keep that in mind. Also, for Mutual Base Exchange, it's a lot harder to do it cross-division.

But not Mexico City

Arado 234 11-30-2021 05:01 PM


Originally Posted by FlyyGuyy (Post 3329244)
But not Mexico City

Depends.

As a "D" pilot you can fly to MEX via PHL, CLT, DFW, PHX and LAX, but not MIA. You need to be "I" qualified to talk to Merida. If it makes no sense to you, ask the schoolhouse. They probably don't know either, but it has always been that way...

Arado 234 11-30-2021 05:05 PM


Originally Posted by EMBFlyer (Post 3329178)
LAX is 320/I. You can always do Out of Base Makeup (as a line holder) in CLT, which is also 320/I. LGA is only 320/D and you won't be International qualified (because it takes 3 days of training to learn to fly to Cancun). So keep that in mind. Also, for Mutual Base Exchange, it's a lot harder to do it cross-division.

I have not gotten a clear answer on cross division pick up. Neither from the union nor the company. I always get a different answer.

crusher 11-30-2021 05:21 PM

I couldn’t even get the schoolhouse to explain why all the Mexico info in the FOM is in the South America chapter. I really thought as a worldwide airline we’d be a little better at geography.

Arado 234 11-30-2021 05:34 PM


Originally Posted by crusher (Post 3329282)
I couldn’t even get the schoolhouse to explain why all the Mexico info in the FOM is in the South America chapter. I really thought as a worldwide airline we’d be a little better at geography.

Try to add an Intl phone number or a foreign address to your personal info! That's fun (not). This is just a big regional airline.

Maybe the other Spanish speaking countries in Latin America get filed under Mexican countries in the next revision.

EMBFlyer 11-30-2021 05:58 PM


Originally Posted by Arado 234 (Post 3329275)
Depends.

As a "D" pilot you can fly to MEX via PHL, CLT, DFW, PHX and LAX, but not MIA. You need to be "I" qualified to talk to Merida. If it makes no sense to you, ask the schoolhouse. They probably don't know either, but it has always been that way...

Just remember, AA only RECENTLY stopped using QFE!

Saabs 11-30-2021 07:24 PM


Originally Posted by EMBFlyer (Post 3329305)
Just remember, AA only RECENTLY stopped using QFE!

as an airways guy I have no idea what qfe is

AllYourBaseAreB 12-01-2021 03:33 AM

It’s when they used to set their altimeter so it would read “zero” on landing, regardless of altitude

thrust 12-01-2021 05:06 AM


Originally Posted by EMBFlyer (Post 3329305)
Just remember, AA only RECENTLY stopped using QFE!

How recently is “RECENTLY”?

nimslow 12-01-2021 05:29 AM


Originally Posted by thrust (Post 3329442)
How recently is “RECENTLY”?

Apparently 30 years ago is "recently".

EMBFlyer 12-01-2021 10:00 AM


Originally Posted by thrust (Post 3329442)
How recently is “RECENTLY”?

Considering the practice generally went away in the 60s (with the exception of Russia), and AA kept it well into the 90s, I'd say that's fairly recent.

95+ years of tradition, unheeded by progress.

Arado 234 12-01-2021 12:37 PM


Originally Posted by EMBFlyer (Post 3329597)
Considering the practice generally went away in the 60s (with the exception of Russia), and AA kept it well into the 90s, I'd say that's fairly recent.

95+ years of tradition, unheeded by progress.

Don't forget the hand motion that was involved with the gear up call. Been there since the DC2, only taken out of the training manual recently.

Saabs 12-01-2021 12:57 PM


Originally Posted by Arado 234 (Post 3329671)
Don't forget the hand motion that was involved with the gear up call. Been there since the DC2, only taken out of the training manual recently.

I don’t see it too much in CLT, but occasionally I do.

FlyyGuyy 12-01-2021 05:17 PM


Originally Posted by Saabs (Post 3329686)
I don’t see it too much in CLT, but occasionally I do.

When I was in Miami, it was everyone.

PRS Guitars 12-01-2021 07:02 PM


Originally Posted by Saabs (Post 3329686)
I don’t see it too much in CLT, but occasionally I do.

Its nearly 100% with LAA guys, I don’t let it bug me, but try not to add any frivolous callouts or hand motions my self

Dobbs18 12-01-2021 07:07 PM


Originally Posted by PRS Guitars (Post 3329856)
Its nearly 100% with LAA guys, I don’t let it bug me, but try not to add any frivolous callouts or hand motions my self

Same....its a muscle memory thing more than anything else so I try to not let it bother me. Most guys try not to do it now, but I am sure there is something I do that has driven someone bonkers but I hope not!

ny797 12-02-2021 04:11 AM


Originally Posted by Arado 234 (Post 3329277)
I have not gotten a clear answer on cross division pick up. Neither from the union nor the company. I always get a different answer.

You can pick up cross division in DOTC for PM/PR (premium makeup/premium reserve) Not sure about MU (makeup, basically straight time) but at this point why would you since everything is going premium. You cannot pickup cross division in TTS.

thrust 12-02-2021 04:44 AM


Originally Posted by Dobbs18 (Post 3329861)
Same....its a muscle memory thing more than anything else so I try to not let it bother me. Most guys try not to do it now, but I am sure there is something I do that has driven someone bonkers but I hope not!

Agree. In terms of “silly/annoying things captains do” the gear gesture doesn’t even move the needle.

Armyguy 12-02-2021 05:01 AM

You can pick up cross division in base via P2P.

aa73 12-02-2021 06:39 PM

1) I’d love to know what this “gear hand gesture” y’all are talking about, as I have been here 21 years (LAA) and have never seen the hand gesture, nor heard it mentioned/taught during training. If it indeed happens it would be amusing to see, but I have never seen it.

2) QFE went away sometime in 1997 I believe, after the BDL tree trimmer. As I recall, the only two US airlines that used QFE into “modern” times were AA and Eastern. Back in the day before radio altimeters it was often praised as a safe procedure to indicate height above the ground at all times, as every ILS would be flown to 200’ on the main altimeters, and they would always read 0’ on the ground. With the advent of the radio altimeter it became a dated practice.

ny797 12-02-2021 09:54 PM

You’ve been here 21 years and don’t know what the gear handle gesture is?! I could care less that some captains do it, but yeah it’s definitely a quirk unique to LAA pilots.

aa73 12-03-2021 02:02 AM


Originally Posted by ny797 (Post 3330397)
You’ve been here 21 years and don’t know what the gear handle gesture is?! I could care less that some captains do it, but yeah it’s definitely a quirk unique to LAA pilots.

No. I don’t know what it is because we have never trained any kind of “hand gesture” in my 21 years here. I’ve been on the 727, 75/76, MD80 and 737… nobody ever said a word about any hand gestures.. the only change I remember at one point is that the PF called out “positive rate gear up” but that was short lived. I’ve ridden countless jumpseats with LAA crews over the years and have yet to see it.
The only time I hear about it is here, on APC.

FlyyGuyy 12-03-2021 03:20 AM


Originally Posted by aa73 (Post 3330411)
No. I don’t know what it is because we have never trained any kind of “hand gesture” in my 21 years here. I’ve been on the 727, 75/76, MD80 and 737… nobody ever said a word about any hand gestures.. the only change I remember at one point is that the PF called out “positive rate gear up” but that was short lived. I’ve ridden countless jumpseats with LAA crews over the years and have yet to see it.
The only time I hear about it is here, on APC.


I would record it for you, but I'm pretty sure that would go over poorly. *Right hand appears in front of fo*. *thumb goes up* *entire hand goes up*. Sometimes this happens without a verbal "gear up" but that's not typical. I'm sure it's leftover from the dc3.

aa73 12-03-2021 04:06 AM

I’m thinking what you saw was an isolated thing (as weird as it sounds) and not necessarily reflective of any kind of training we ever received at LAA, because I never remember being taught anything like that. It was ALWAYS Positive Rate Gear Up and the PM raised the gear… period end of story. But can’t say I’m surprised to read about it here on APC as anything LAA whether real or fabricated is immediately subject to all kinds of ridicule. (and in this case it would be justified…)

AllYourBaseAreB 12-03-2021 04:07 AM

Guard those auto throttles!!!!!

TallFlyer 12-03-2021 04:50 AM


Originally Posted by AllYourBaseAreB (Post 3330434)
Guard those auto throttles!!!!!


Imagine if that Asiana crew had that procedure…..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Andrew_VT 12-03-2021 08:44 AM

aa73 I normally agree with you but on this you're crazy. I see the hand gesture from ~50% of LAA Captains I fly with.

AllYourBaseAreB 12-03-2021 09:33 AM

imagine if that Asiana crew listened to the FO in the Jumpseat or had any scan what-so-ever


Originally Posted by TallFlyer (Post 3330452)
Imagine if that Asiana crew had that procedure…..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Al Czervik 12-03-2021 02:12 PM


Originally Posted by TallFlyer (Post 3330452)
Imagine if that Asiana crew had that procedure…..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

This posts shows a lack of understanding of multiple things.

aa73 12-03-2021 02:12 PM


Originally Posted by Andrew_VT (Post 3330553)
aa73 I normally agree with you but on this you're crazy. I see the hand gesture from ~50% of LAA Captains I fly with.

OK then. See ya

Dobbs18 12-03-2021 03:24 PM


Originally Posted by aa73 (Post 3330433)
I’m thinking what you saw was an isolated thing (as weird as it sounds) and not necessarily reflective of any kind of training we ever received at LAA, because I never remember being taught anything like that. It was ALWAYS Positive Rate Gear Up and the PM raised the gear… period end of story. But can’t say I’m surprised to read about it here on APC as anything LAA whether real or fabricated is immediately subject to all kinds of ridicule. (and in this case it would be justified…)

I can also attest that it is not an “isolated” thing and it is 100% only done by legacy AA pilots…again it’s not a big deal, but it is definitely not fabricated either.

Al Czervik 12-03-2021 05:07 PM

Basic questions about QOL at AA
 

Originally Posted by aa73 (Post 3330433)
I’m thinking what you saw was an isolated thing (as weird as it sounds)


https://media2.giphy.com/media/wYyTHMm50f4Dm/giphy.gif

dera 12-03-2021 06:09 PM


Originally Posted by aa73 (Post 3330352)
1) I’d love to know what this “gear hand gesture” y’all are talking about, as I have been here 21 years (LAA) and have never seen the hand gesture, nor heard it mentioned/taught during training. If it indeed happens it would be amusing to see, but I have never seen it.

2) QFE went away sometime in 1997 I believe, after the BDL tree trimmer. As I recall, the only two US airlines that used QFE into “modern” times were AA and Eastern. Back in the day before radio altimeters it was often praised as a safe procedure to indicate height above the ground at all times, as every ILS would be flown to 200’ on the main altimeters, and they would always read 0’ on the ground. With the advent of the radio altimeter it became a dated practice.

Whoever thought that was safe was an idiot. Probably the same guy who came up with F16 maneuvers to control a passenger jet in wake turbulence.

PRS Guitars 12-03-2021 06:47 PM


Originally Posted by dera (Post 3330761)
Whoever thought that was safe was an idiot. Probably the same guy who came up with F16 maneuvers to control a passenger jet in wake turbulence.

F16 maneuvers? No, that’s not what that was.

Hueypilot 12-03-2021 07:04 PM

The "gear up/down" hand gesture was a fairly common practice amongst USAF heavy drivers back in the day, and in the T-37 if I remember correctly. That practice has steadily died away, though. Some things, when drilled into someone's head, just can't be removed. In the C-130 world, it used to be standard practice but it was taken out of the regs many years ago...but there were a number of old guys who just wouldn't let it go.

Kebert Xela 12-03-2021 07:19 PM

Seen it plenty on the line. Different ways also; open hand I dream of Jeannie style, thumbs up, to just a hand out and point at the handle.

C130s it’s still common practice for verbal&visual due to crew coordination since depending on the variant of aircraft it’s not a 2 person cockpit.

Big picture… does it matter?

TallFlyer 12-03-2021 08:17 PM


Originally Posted by Al Czervik (Post 3330672)
This posts shows a lack of understanding of multiple things.


I’ve never flown an aircraft with AT so perhaps you’re right.

At the same time a hand very close to or on the thrust levers might’ve been a good clue to the two guys in the pilot seats that something was amiss. AYB makes some good points too.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Arado 234 12-03-2021 10:48 PM


Originally Posted by Hueypilot (Post 3330776)
The "gear up/down" hand gesture was a fairly common practice amongst USAF heavy drivers back in the day, and in the T-37 if I remember correctly. That practice has steadily died away, though. Some things, when drilled into someone's head, just can't be removed. In the C-130 world, it used to be standard practice but it was taken out of the regs many years ago...but there were a number of old guys who just wouldn't let it go.

Like monitoring guard while on the taxiway or ramp? I had ask one skipper (with a certain guard rep) one day, if he'd monitored guard on his way to the airport. He didn't get it. Otherwise, nice guy to fly with.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:46 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands