![]() |
COVID-19 SURVIVORS Disqualified from Military
Stigma or precaution? DoD memo lists Covid-19 as ‘permanently disqualifying’ for survivors seeking to join army
https://www.rt.com/usa/487984-corona...-military-ban/ So what’s going on here? Is there something we’re not being told? |
You are aware that RT started out as Russia Today? They aren’t the most reliable source for info about the US military.
Having said that, epidemics among recruits in basic training have ALWAYS been a problem. https://www.ajpmonline.org/article/S...08)00163-3/pdf It would not surprise me if they barred anyone with a history if COVID from being recruited until they can come up with procedures to assure nobody is spreading the virus before they let them into basic training. It wouldn’t even surprise me if they didn’t take them until there was a vaccine available.The list of immunizations routinely given in basic training is quite extensive: https://www.thebalancecareers.com/mi...ations-4058318 Bringing a bunch of people in from all over the US and putting them into the same barracks entails considerable risk for meningitis and other diseases that may be brought in by immune carriers to a disease and rapidly spread in the boot camp environment. |
COVID-19 can cause permanent lung damage. Maybe they feel that the risk of compromised soldiers with reduced lung capacity is not worth the trouble?
|
RT?
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahaha |
Originally Posted by Excargodog
(Post 3050629)
You are aware that RT started out as Russia Today? They aren’t the most reliable source for info about the US military.
Having said that, epidemics among recruits in basic training have ALWAYS been a problem. https://www.ajpmonline.org/article/S...08)00163-3/pdf It would not surprise me if they barred anyone with a history if COVID from being recruited until they can come up with procedures to assure nobody is spreading the virus before they let them into basic training. It wouldn’t even surprise me if they didn’t take them until there was a vaccine available.The list of immunizations routinely given in basic training is quite extensive: https://www.thebalancecareers.com/mi...ations-4058318 Bringing a bunch of people in from all over the US and putting them into the same barracks entails considerable risk for meningitis and other diseases that may be brought in by immune carriers to a disease and rapidly spread in the boot camp environment. Besides the point, I’m very well aware of what RT is. I hold dual citizenship and I’ve resided in Russia for more than 6 years and I can tell you that Voice of America (RT’s “propaganda” competition) couldn’t hold water for **** there. We can reserve this argument for a different thread/different day though. |
|
Originally Posted by senecacaptain
(Post 3050651)
|
Originally Posted by WutFace
(Post 3050638)
COVID-19 can cause permanent lung damage. Maybe they feel that the risk of compromised soldiers with reduced lung capacity is not worth the trouble?
|
That will probably continue till there is a vaccine. I wonder if there will be any effect on FAA medical certification?
|
Originally Posted by Burt123
(Post 3050653)
Wow that’s like almost point blank the same exact article that I’ve posted, but this time the “source” is coming from “military times” so it must be true. Thank you, this thread might now become worthy of conservable now...
Look, I didn’t FAIL to discuss the issue. As I posted, anytime you shove a bunch of recruits from different areas of the country into a basic training barracks you create a situation ripe for disease spread. Over 15% of people are asymptomatic strep carriers: https://www.cdc.gov/groupastrep/dise...ep-throat.html From 10 to 35% of people are asymptomatic carriers for neisseria meningitidis, the causative agent for meningitis. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2719693/ same goes for adenoviruses and other organisms. https://homelandprepnews.com/counter...virus-vaccine/ While most people have been exposed to and are immune to the strains from their own geographical regions when you shove a bunch of people from different regions with different strains together frequently all h€|| breaks lose, which is why about the first thing that happens in basic training is that the trainees get immunizations for a lot of things that the general public neither gets nor needs. it is not in the least unreasonable that the military take action to bar people who might be asymptomatic carriers until the details of coronavirus infection in the US population are fully worked out, and depending on those details, even until a vaccine is available. |
Originally Posted by WutFace
(Post 3050638)
COVID-19 can cause permanent lung damage. Maybe they feel that the risk of compromised soldiers with reduced lung capacity is not worth the trouble?
ANY severe viral infection can cause permanent lung damage, even just the flu: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/...?dopt=Abstract Coronavirus - in young healthy people - doesn’t seem to cause that a great deal more than any other respiratory virus. It is now starting to become obvious that the whole ‘OMIGAWD, WE DON’T HAVE ENOUGH RESPIRATORS!’ thing was overdone. Too many people were put on too many respirators too early with disastrous results. A respirator is a potentially lethal device and demands specifically trained medical and nursing personnel to manage people effectively. Under NORMAL circumstances a relatively small cadre of physicians In each facility are specIfically credentialed for their use and generally only post op and ICU nurses attend these patients. Some of what happened was akin to putting a 50 hr private pilot in charge of an A-10 and sending them out to strafe bad guys. Expecting Joe average doc to manage patients optimally on a ventilator was a recipe for disaster. Today they are much more reticent to do early intubation and ventilator use: https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/21/...n-ventilators/ |
It's not an issue of spreading the virus or lung damage. Hospitalized patients are often intubation. Long term intubation leads to cognative dysfunction and multiple system and organ damage. Also, recovered patients not intubated are showing signs of cognative damage. Along with unknown residual long term health issues post infection, conservatively better to disqualify.
I'm sure the FAA will have a special issuance medical protocol as well. That would not be a good thing for us. |
Yeah, I have been thinking this entire time, that if you get/had covid, the FAA might start requiring the Astronaut physical to keep a 1st class cert. That could put thousands of pilots out of work, even with their non-covid conditions.
|
If you’re not sick enough to be hospitalized, you shouldn’t have anything to worry about WRT lung damage.
There’s plenty of people out there who had this with symptoms and were never diagnosed, or had it and were totally asymptomatic, or had it and only had loss of smell/taste. |
Originally Posted by Mesabah
(Post 3051022)
Yeah, I have been thinking this entire time, that if you get/had covid, the FAA might start requiring the Astronaut physical to keep a 1st class cert. That could put thousands of pilots out of work, even with their non-covid conditions.
besides, a lot of their ow center controllers have been hit by this and as soon as they’ve been diagnosed as recovered and no longer shedding virus sent them right back to work. And serious, you couldn’t pass an astronaut physical..? ;) |
Originally Posted by BoilerUP
(Post 3051025)
If you’re not sick enough to be hospitalized, you shouldn’t have anything to worry about WRT lung damage.
There’s plenty of people out there who had this with symptoms and were never diagnosed, or had it and were totally asymptomatic, or had it and only had loss of smell/taste. Yeah, 96%+ of the prison convicts who tested positive were unaware they were even sick. And that’s roughly the age group we are talking about. Clearly, this CAN be a deadly disease. Just as clearly it USUALLY is nothing of the sort. |
Originally Posted by Excargodog
(Post 3051034)
I doubt it seriously. The FAA has long contended that their standard neuropsych eval is entirely adequate for catching Alzheimer’s, stroke residuals, and other cognitive degradation. They’ve never required it post influenza, herpes, or other viral illnesses that can also cause cognitive issues post recovery and even for people with ACTIVE HIV not yet diagnosed as AIDS they only require a standard neurocognitive screen., nothing really all that cosmic.
besides, a lot of their ow center controllers have been hit by this and as soon as they’ve been diagnosed as recovered and no longer shedding virus sent them right back to work. And serious, you couldn’t pass an astronaut physical..? ;) Herpes that causes acute necrotizing encephalitis will certainly land you in special issuance territory with a cog screen. Medexpess requires hospitalizations and disability insurance received to be reported... than the faa just follows its protocols to issue a regular or special issuance. I'm sure there will be a difference in the protocol from having rona, mild symptoms and requiring admission to the hospital. Plenty of pilots have horror stories with their medicals, I hope the rona doesn't make this career even harder for some. |
I get concerned anytime you put cognitive and FAA in the same sentence. With Rona we've crossed into another realm medically because no one really knows what it can or can't do. The FAA tends to leans conservative without a lot of hard data one way or another. A lot of health issues are visible for examination. Cognitive issues don't always present as black and white. Remember that conversation on cognitive decline from two lifetimes ago in context with age 65 and above for pilot age limits?
|
Originally Posted by aeroengineer
(Post 3051109)
I get concerned anytime you put cognitive and FAA in the same sentence. With Rona we've crossed into another realm medically because no one really knows what it can or can't do. The FAA tends to leans conservative without a lot of hard data one way or another. A lot of health issues are visible for examination. Cognitive issues don't always present as black and white. Remember that conversation on cognitive decline from two lifetimes ago in context with age 65 and above for pilot age limits?
No particular reason to think it will have lingering effects in most people (any virus can have a weird course and cause longer-term issues in some people, but most people clear this kind of virus and recover fully). The FAA is not going to ground people based on a positive COVID test... that might end up shutting down the air transport system even if the economy doesn't. We all get cog screens anyway... our primary cog screens are annual/semi-annual sim rides and the casual conversation you have with your AME every six months. That later is also your mental health assessment. |
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:33 AM. |
Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands