I had a terrible experience with A Cut Above last year. Their customer service took a dive apparently. They did eventually do the right thing but it required pulling many teeth.

Anybody try whitepilotshirts.com?

The Crew Outfitters Platinum are the best I’ve ever worn, after years of being a ACA loyalist. Best part is you can try them on and buy them in the A lounge store on your next ATL sit and skip the shipping and returns.

I’ve switched to Pact for undershirts, been happy.

For the Costco faithful out there…the Cool32 tshirts are back in stock in my store.

A Cut Above Brooks all the way! Super soft, cool, comfortable. Only downside is you have to iron them. I wear the Tropo in the winter. A little thicker and they don’t require ironing.

I agree, these are very nice.

These feel like plastic to me.

I'm swearing by the Airman shirts right now. I have the softer of their two main fabrics, and it feels similar to a Vuori shirt, it's the best feeling dress shirt (as much as a pilot shirt is one) I've ever worn. You can also wad it into a ball at the bottom of your bag, and it'll be wrinkle free after hanging in the closet overnight.

My only complaint is that it pills easily, I think it's my ID lanyard that's causing it. I will try their standard fabric next time.

I'm gonna test these out. I've been an ACA fitted tropo wearer for like 15 years, but I never know what I'm gonna get when I order from them. Would you suggest the fitted or slim? Do they need ironing or can you just take them out of the dryer and hang them and they're good to go?

I haven't tried them yet (just waiting for my current Flight shirts to wear out), but several of my buddies have started using BomCrewMall and absolutely love it. Very customized, the dude will send you a test shirt for your to make measurements on, and makes sure your shirt is perfectly tailored to you. Not the cheapest option but not outrageous, especially for the great quality and customer service.