Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Flight Schools and Training (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/flight-schools-training/)
-   -   IFR above freezing level (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/flight-schools-training/20020-ifr-above-freezing-level.html)

Bri85 12-19-2007 11:06 PM


Originally Posted by iflyjets4food (Post 283047)
question answered...

there's a chart that has it depicted along with many other things, but I don't recall what it was called. Airmets should give you the freezing level as well.

you got it freezing level charts.


i use
http://adds.aviationweather.noaa.gov/



-I was told even equip for icing conditions 18nm is the limit when flying into icing conditions :confused:

SongMan 12-20-2007 06:43 AM


Originally Posted by the King (Post 283705)
1. There's a possibility of a temperature inversion or potentially climbing to VMC when the clouds and freezing level are low. Not guaranteed, but possible. The #1 priority is to get out of the ice. If you are IMC and have no way to tell where the ground is, best bet is to climb. No one has ever collided with the air.

2. Water droplets can actually be cooled below freezing without turning to ice. This phenomenon is called super-cooled water droplets. The water has nothing to freeze on since it is suspended in the air. But if it is super-cooled, the moment it touches something (wings) it will freeze. Below -20 degrees it is highly unlikely there is anything liquid, but between 0 and -20, you have to beware of the potential for ice.


Thanks you!

So we climb in icing condition incasee of temp inversion? or is it to climb to an altitude that will give below -20 Degrees to stop icing from further developing?

Also, is supercooled water droplets the only cause for icing? Can a mist or fog be supercooled and cause icing?

patton33 12-20-2007 07:03 AM

well the cause for icing is generally temperatures at or below freezing (sometimes +2 but that's a different debate) and visible or present moisture. Don't have to be in the clouds to pick up ice, frost can and will form at night. In regards to the super cooled water, water can be super cooled from 0 all the way to -40 C, after that it becomes a suspended ice particle.

As for the climbing in icing conditions, generally speaking attempting to out climb the ice is a bad plan for light GA aircraft as it generally cannot be done. Depending on the severity of the ice, the performance of the aircraft and the altitude you are at, you'll never be able to climb above it. It can sometimes be done/be a good idea, especially if its a thin cloud layer or as you said there is a strong temperature inversion but generally speaking, no.

An additional factor to look at when it comes to ice, is what type of precip is occurring and what is the temperature. There are three types of ice, clear, rime and mix and they each form with different types of precip and temperatures.

When it comes to icing and GA aircraft the rule of thumb i use is that if it is +3 or colder at the MEA, its a no go. If there are pireps or airmets up for ice, also a no go.

SongMan 12-20-2007 07:08 AM


Originally Posted by patton33 (Post 283826)

When it comes to icing and GA aircraft the rule of thumb i use is that if it is +3 or colder at the MEA, its a no go. If there are pireps or airmets up for ice, also a no go.

+3 or colder in MEA? You mean with visible moisture, right? or regardless of visible moisture, you don't go with temp being +3 or colder?

thanks

patton33 12-20-2007 07:12 AM

i factor in visible moisture, cloud bases, cloud types.

Its especially important in the mountainous environment where I instruct because the MEA (or sometimes even the MOCA) is at 10k feet which generally means there really is no climbing and there is no going down unless its for an approach or youve found VFR.

That and forecast products can and have been wrong, very wrong and I don't want to get up there and discover that first hand :).

de727ups 12-20-2007 09:00 AM

"climbing in icing conditions, generally speaking attempting to out climb the ice is a bad plan for light GA aircraft as it generally cannot be done"

I agree.

Always leave yourself and out and, if you start getting ice, use it. That said, I think you can do a lot during the winter months. You aren't a seasoned IFR pilot until you've seen, and dealt with, icing conditions.

patton33 12-20-2007 11:50 AM

yes, what it all comes down to with icing and light aircraft is ALWAYS having an out.

DamonMeyer 12-20-2007 07:53 PM


Originally Posted by patton33 (Post 284061)
yes, what it all comes down to with icing and light aircraft is ALWAYS having an out.

I'll second that emotion. And the out should not be a climb, e.g. to the warmer temps above indicated by the freezing rain you've encountered. For ice potential in a small plane, the out should be a quick 180 or a good margin below of air between the feezing layer and the ground.

snippercr 12-21-2007 08:27 AM

Thanks for all the input so far guys.

So riddle me this...I wanted to go IFR today. Temp/dew was 02/01 visiblity was 2sm, cig was ovc at 600 feet. Lovely weather to gather some actual instrument time!
However, using the 2deg/1000 feet, that means once I climb 1000 feet, I will be at the freezing level. Does this constitute known icing conditions both in the aspect of safety and legality?
aviationweather doesnt show any air/sigmets for icing over the area nor where there any pireps of any type of icing.
What do I Make of that? Is it best that I didnt go or given the lack of pireps/forcasted ice should I have gone as long as I had safety outs (a general consensus here).
Edit: Incidentally I checked the winds aloft and temps showed +C all the way up to over 6000 feet. I am confused... would this be a temperature inversion since its actually warmer above us? See previous metar.

patton33 12-21-2007 10:18 AM

I usually use an upper air sounding to determine temp/dp spread aloft. in regards to the ceiling info you posted, especially if you have little to no time in actual, establish a personal minimum for yourself that AT LEAST meets the minimums of the highest circling approach.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:31 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands