Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Foreign (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/foreign/)
-   -   Korean Denies Dying Woman Seat (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/foreign/59265-korean-denies-dying-woman-seat.html)

vagabond 05-09-2011 06:36 PM

Korean Denies Dying Woman Seat
 
Finally a story that apparently has nothing to do with terrorists!



SEATAC, Wash. – A woman dying of breast cancer found herself in a battle with an airline as she tried to fly to South Korea from Sea-Tac Airport over the weekend.

Despite clearances from two different doctors, Korean Air refused to let Crystal Kim board their plane.

"I wanted to take my mom there for Mother's Day," said Crystal's daughter, Mimi.

But when they went to check in, the Kims said Korean Air told them Crystal look too frail to fly.


Airline denies dying woman seat on Sea-Tac flight | KING5.com Seattle

Typhoonpilot 05-09-2011 10:20 PM

I can tell you that I have taken a dying man from JFK to DXB once and I will never do it again. The man had doctor notes and clearances, but the flight was a nightmare. We were in almost constant contact with Medlink and had a couple of onboard doctors looking after him the whole way. It wasn't fair to the other passengers for that man to be on the airplane.

Commercial airliners are not meant for dying people to be riding on. If a person has a terminal illness they need to go back to their home country much earlier in the process or pay for a dedicated air ambulance.

Korean most likely did the right thing in this case.



Typhoonpilot

captjns 05-09-2011 10:44 PM

Our airline permits the transport of critical care patients for medical treatment. A stretcher is set up in the last row of the aircraft. A certified physician must accompany the ill passenger.

DYNASTY HVY 05-10-2011 03:47 AM

slow news day ?
 
No prob. It appears that DAL came to her rescue.:D




Fred

B757200ER 05-10-2011 08:23 PM


Originally Posted by Typhoonpilot (Post 991606)
I can tell you that I have taken a dying man from JFK to DXB once and I will never do it again. The man had doctor notes and clearances, but the flight was a nightmare. We were in almost constant contact with Medlink and had a couple of onboard doctors looking after him the whole way. It wasn't fair to the other passengers for that man to be on the airplane.

Commercial airliners are not meant for dying people to be riding on. If a person has a terminal illness they need to go back to their home country much earlier in the process or pay for a dedicated air ambulance.

Korean most likely did the right thing in this case.

Typhoonpilot

TP---100% right, I agree. I've had it happen before, and it is a constant hassle with cabin crew & pax. Airlines should be able to deny boarding to passengers who may not survive the trip.

EXPAT1 05-11-2011 12:57 AM

Watch the video before you pass judgment. I agree it is no fun to be the Captain and Cabin crew dealing with a medical crisis but this woman is clearly able to fly. Two different doctors approved this and from the womans appearance she can withstand the flight. Apparently Delta came through for her and saved the day. I think Korean lost some customers with this debacle.

Cat stuck in pipe rescued

Typhoonpilot 05-11-2011 01:34 AM


Originally Posted by EXPAT1 (Post 992034)
Watch the video before you pass judgment. I agree it is no fun to be the Captain and Cabin crew dealing with a medical crisis but this woman is clearly able to fly. Two different doctors approved this and from the womans appearance she can withstand the flight. Apparently Delta came through for her and saved the day. I think Korean lost some customers with this debacle.

Cat stuck in pipe rescued



The problem is this: They may look okay while sitting on the ground, but put them in an economy class seat on a long haul flight; climb up to a cabin altitude of 8000 feet; then see how they are. Usually that person who looked okay on the ground starts having trouble breathing; their pulse slows; they drift in and out of consciousness. You have no way of judging how they will fair nor do the doctors who are writing the notes for them.



Typhoonpilot

KoruPilot 05-11-2011 05:51 AM

Yup,

Then you have to drop into HNL, after dumping tons of fuel, because if you don't the person (in the case that happened to me) will be dead by the time you're abeam Fiji.

It happens more than the general public obviously knows, and in many cases by the time the you hit ground the patient is a corpse. Not a lot of fun, the cabin crew is freaked, the flight crew is forced to make decisions above their pay grade, and it's simply not worth it.

As for doctors, you get this a lot out of the S Pacific Islands and trust me, getting a doctors clearance is just not that difficult.

EXPAT1 05-12-2011 05:05 AM

Again watch the video before passing judgment. Thank goodness some Delta pilots, staff and crew demonstrated some compassion and judgment and now this woman is able to peacefully pass away in her home country with family and loved ones. I agree with TP and Koru that this is a difficult situation to be placed in as a captain and crew but clearly this woman was able to fly and now she is safely in Korea. Each passenger must be individually evaluated. Korean will lose customers in the Seattle area because of this heart wrenching story.

Airline denies dying woman seat on Sea-Tac flight

quinny89 05-12-2011 10:27 AM


Originally Posted by EXPAT1 (Post 992615)
Korean will lose customers in the Seattle area because of this heart wrenching story.

No they won't. People pick an airline because of how cheap the ticket price is, if you think someone's going to fly on another airline that costs $100's more than Korean, just because of this story, you're kidding yourself.

Sorry, it's a hard world nowadays, and if your skin isn't thick enough, you're in for a rough time.

Molon Labe 05-12-2011 11:44 AM

Flying transpacific on the 747 for a long time at NWA we used to take people home to die, usually the Phillipines being the ultimate destination..And the program worked that the patient had a block area of about 5 seats laid down in a hospital bed config.....The doctor "clearances" also had a do not resusitate (spelling error) order included. So the net effect if the person expired or more likely started to expire we did absolutely nothing about it...We would chug along our merry way and deliver the deceased to the land that they wanted to die in....The protocol was to NOT have a physician declare the patient dead...Until that person was where he or she got to destination....Maybe Delta got a similar "clearance" .......

vagabond 05-14-2011 12:52 PM

I was siding with this woman until I read that (1) they called the media almost as soon as the airline said no to them and (2) they are now considering a lawsuit. Some people just have to get in their 15 minutes of notoriety. Next time I want to fly First Class, I'll try this same trick. I'll cry and carry on in front of everybody and the cameras. I'll have my own Facebook page and also tweet every few minutes.

Terminally ill Seattle woman arrives in S. Korea, ending airline ordeal | KING5.com Seattle

rotorhead1026 05-14-2011 01:44 PM


Originally Posted by vagabond (Post 993618)
they are now considering a lawsuit.

Gee, I wonder what the defense strategy will be? You don't think they'll try any delaying tactics, do you? :D

mikeypat15 05-14-2011 07:00 PM

I once heard that air crews are requested to not say someone has "died" but "absence of vital signs" or something along those lines. Reason being if someone dies on board the aircraft must be quarantined. Any truth to this?

CE750 05-14-2011 07:04 PM

that's odd... and here I am sitting in their First Class lounge because they bumped me from Business to First for no apparent reason....

The Dominican 05-14-2011 10:55 PM


Originally Posted by mikeypat15 (Post 993729)
I once heard that air crews are requested to not say someone has "died" but "absence of vital signs" or something along those lines. Reason being if someone dies on board the aircraft must be quarantined. Any truth to this?

The reason is because legally only a medical doctor can determine death, not even a trained paramedic can pronounce death, only the absence of "vital signs" and that is why the declaration of death is "on arrival" when somebody passes away on an ambulance. As a matter of fact, you shouldn't even say absence of vital signs if you are not a trained medical professional because they can come back and really nail you for making that determination, rather just limit the report as the individual being unresponsive; declare an emergency, descend, land and let the emergency responders deal with it.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:07 PM.


User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Website Copyright ©2000 - 2017 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands