Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Major (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/)
-   -   United vs Southwest vs Atlas (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/140347-united-vs-southwest-vs-atlas.html)

FlyyGuyy 11-14-2022 11:39 AM


Originally Posted by NotMrNiceGuy (Post 3531593)
10 minute turn in HGR? That’s legit.

I remember sitting at an airport restaurant in Franklin Pennsylvania and a 1900 lands, handful of people hop off/on. Number 2 still running. And off they went. I was working on my private and I was blown away by how fast that went down.

dera 11-14-2022 12:10 PM


Originally Posted by Otterbox (Post 3531670)
Hands down United… you can pick narrow body your first year, get a bunch of hours then bid 777 or 787. SWA you’re on a 737 for eternity… Atlas, pretty sure their 5-6 year widebody guys make about the same a 2nd year 777FO at UAL. Atlas lags greatly in pay and retirement for the effort of work put in.

5-6 year WB guys (captains) make ~270/hr at Atlas. We have 3 year FOs making 300k here.
Agree about the effort, but the money isn't that bad right now.

Logged 11-14-2022 12:24 PM

Allagiant without a doubt.

goinaround 11-14-2022 12:58 PM


Originally Posted by dera (Post 3531717)
5-6 year WB guys (captains) make ~270/hr at Atlas. We have 3 year FOs making 300k here.
Agree about the effort, but the money isn't that bad right now.

3 year FOs based in Anchorage doing china flying and maybe picking up some days on top of the 17. Nothing to make future plans on. The bonus China money is temporary. Don’t think you’d be doing the guy a favor by talking him into Atlas over a Legacy.

dera 11-14-2022 01:32 PM


Originally Posted by goinaround (Post 3531769)
3 year FOs based in Anchorage doing china flying and maybe picking up some days on top of the 17. Nothing to make future plans on. The bonus China money is temporary. Don’t think you’d be doing the guy a favor by talking him into Atlas over a Legacy.

I was the first one to reply to this thread. See post #2.


Originally Posted by dera (Post 3531110)
United, by a country mile.


BLMPilot 11-14-2022 03:27 PM


Originally Posted by ZapBrannigan (Post 3531544)
Regional slave ships? Aren't you guys getting paid six figures with a guaranteed flow now? Hardly slave labor.

When I started at the commuters it was $13,000 per year salary, plus we had to pay for our own training for a 19 seat turboprop with no autopilot, no cockpit door, and no coffee maker, flying 6-10 legs per day. THAT was a slave ship (and looking back on it, I loved every minute of it!) https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...a4b52f4bc4.jpg

You deserve to pay dues because of born privilege.

TheFly 11-14-2022 05:14 PM

1. Drive to work.
2. Ask yourself, what kind of flying do you want to do?

BLMPilot 11-14-2022 05:25 PM


Originally Posted by TheFly (Post 3531881)
1. Drive to work.
2. Ask yourself, what kind of flying do you want to do?

Only the ultimate privileged live in legacy hubs with abundant airframe choices. Must be nice to have choices so easy.

goinaround 11-14-2022 06:09 PM


Originally Posted by BLMPilot (Post 3531886)
Only the ultimate privileged live in legacy hubs with abundant airframe choices. Must be nice to have choices so easy.

I like your style…..but I don’t think any suckers are gonna bite.

hockeypilot44 11-15-2022 11:18 AM


Originally Posted by JetRider35 (Post 3531106)
Hello Guys,

I know there are many topics like this thread. However, my situation is a little bit different. I hope you can give me your best opinion about it! Thank you in advance.

Let me start with myself first. I'm not American and I have a green card. I always wanted to work as a pilot in the USA. Right now, I'm living in Dubai and flying B777. I recently resigned from my job and I'm in my notice period (3 Months! Yes you didn't read it wrong. It's 3 months). I have 4600 Jet hours (B777 and B737) and 0 PIC. I always flew as a FO in airlines. I got my unrestricted FAA ATP in AUG 2022 and I started applying for jobs after that. Until now, I got CJO from United, Southwest, and Atlas.

I also want to share my plan so that you can help me to choose the best for myself. I don't have close family in the US. Therefore I can live anywhere. I can make my home wherever I'm based at. I won't commute. I want to maximize my earnings over time. Also, I want to work smart not hard. Therefore, I would love to go to a company where I can maximize my earnings (upgrade time, contractual benefits, etc.,) and then want to have a nice lifestyle.


I'm not familiar with the part 121 world. I try to read here a lot. However, sometimes it takes too much time to understand contractual terms and abbreviations. I believe I will be better in time :).


As far as I read, upgrade times are very short in the United right now. However, I have to fly 1000 hours before the upgrade either way since I don't have part 121 hours. However, I can be assigned to a wide body where it can take up to years to collect 1000 hours for the upgrade. On the other hand, If I'm assigned to an NB, do you think that with the new contract (if they fix the Reserve system) upgrades take years in United? They will hire more than 200 pilots next year and retirement rates are huge. In a couple of years, I can be on top of thousands of pilots on the seniority list.

Southwest, as far as I understand upgrade times are long. They say 6-7 years. However, in the interview they said, Upgrade times will be significantly shorter in the future since they are planning to increase the B737 fleet to 1000 aircraft. I know It's a projection and there is a huge room where the expected 3-4 years upgrade is not possible any soon. They will hire more than 2000 pilots and I can be on top of these 2000 guys in a year.

Atlas, I'm assigned to the B777 fleet. All flights are long-range. It looks like for the first 1-2 year I can more money than any others. However, 401K, Worklife, etc, is not great compared to United and Southwest. Upgrade times for B747 and B777 are around 6 years currently

Taking my situation into account, what would you choose for me? I want to work for a company for life from now on. I'm 33 and I've already changed 2 companies. I want to settle in and don't want to change companies anymore. From the short and long perspective,e taking into account stability, financial security, salary, upgrade times, quality of life, and future plans of the company which company should I choose? and in what order should I choose the companies? (if something goes wrong with the first option)

Thank you very much.

United, Southwest, then Atlas.

This is easy decision. Atlas is a lower tier job. No offense to Atlas pilots, but overall it is. Shouldn’t even be a consideration.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:04 PM.


User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Website Copyright ©2000 - 2017 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands