Go Back  Airline Pilot Central Forums > Airline Pilot Forums > Major
What SWA Could Teach Delta and American >

What SWA Could Teach Delta and American

Notices
Major Legacy, National, and LCC

What SWA Could Teach Delta and American

Old 07-16-2008, 11:13 AM
  #1  
Livin' the Dream
Thread Starter
 
Metal121's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Dec 2005
Posts: 84
Default What SWA Could Teach Delta and American

Interesting article.

What Southwest Airlines Could Teach Delta and American

Posted by Heidi N. Moore
There is an interesting dichotomy at play in the airline industry: some airlines are actually profiting from rising oil prices.
Consider Delta Air Lines’ earnings today. The Atlanta airline, which has agreed to combine with Northwest Airlines, announced a $1.04 billion second-quarter net loss, partly because of rising fuel costs. But it could have been far worse. Delta actually earned a tidy bundle on the rising price of oil–more, in fact, than it counted in earnings this quarter.
Associated PressDelta, with the help of its Wall Street investment bankers, created hedges to protect its business against rising oil prices. But as the our paper reported today, “Delta hedged 49% of its fuel consumption and realized about $313 million in gains.” Delta’s earnings this quarter–excluding write-downs–were only $137 million.
American Airlines wasn’t as lucky, since its hedges missed the mark by a long shot. In June, AMR revealed it had hedges on about 33% of fuel consumption. Taken in aggregate, it bet that oil prices wouldn’t rise above $78 a barrel this year. Oil today is at around $136 a barrel.
On the other side of the coin, consider Southwest Airlines. It has about $5 billion of fuel hedges, or about half of its market cap. Morgan Stanley analyst William Greene Tuesday went as far as to call Southwest an “oil play,” and complained that airlines’ fuel hedges cover a multitude of sins and may be an excuse for the airline to avoid cutting capacity. Greene wrote: “Considering that [Southwest’s] management recently suggested it may revisit its capacity plans and potentially raise growth suggests that management does not view its fuel hedge as a temporary comparative advantage but rather as a durable competitive advantage. Not addressing the company’s economic challenges today may lead to a more difficult adjustment in the future.”
The question, as always, is whether capacity cuts are what the industry needs. Greene believes they are. Still, late last week he presented several reasons why airlines would want to avoid any extensive cuts in capacity and “chase oil” instead. In his words:
(1) The network effect of a hub-and-spoke model deteriorates as capacity is cut
(2) Labor contracts, fleet planning, and aircraft/facility financing make large capacity cuts difficult to reverse in the short-term
(3) An habitual (if currently muted) focus on maintaining and gaining market share
(4) An inability to predict competitive responses
(5) Lack of visibility in airline revenue trends
(6) Uncertainty surrounding oil prices, a pullback could quickly make many routes profitabl
Employees who made significant concessions in union negotiations are going to be watching that bottom line very carefully — especially the pilots at Delta and Northwest. As Delta noted today, “Pilots at both companies will receive pay raises and an equity stake in the combined company.” That money has to come from somewhere.
Metal121 is offline  
Old 07-16-2008, 02:10 PM
  #2  
Gets Weekends Off
 
cfii2007's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Jul 2007
Posts: 1,213
Default

[quote=Metal121;426987]Interesting article.

What Southwest Airlines Could Teach Delta and American

Posted by Heidi N. Moore
There is an interesting dichotomy at play in the airline industry: some airlines are actually profiting from rising oil prices.
Consider Delta Air Lines’ earnings today. The Atlanta airline, which has agreed to combine with Northwest Airlines, announced a $1.04 billion second-quarter net loss, partly because of rising fuel costs. But it could have been far worse. Delta actually earned a tidy bundle on the rising price of oil–more, in fact, than it counted in earnings this quarter.
Associated PressDelta, with the help of its Wall Street investment bankers, created hedges to protect its business against rising oil prices. But as the our paper reported today, “Delta hedged 49% of its fuel consumption and realized about $313 million in gains.” Delta’s earnings this quarter–excluding write-downs–were only $137 million.
American Airlines wasn’t as lucky, since its hedges missed the mark by a long shot. In June, AMR revealed it had hedges on about 33% of fuel consumption. Taken in aggregate, it bet that oil prices wouldn’t rise above $78 a barrel this year. Oil today is at around $136 a barrel.
On the other side of the coin, consider Southwest Airlines. It has about $5 billion of fuel hedges, or about half of its market cap. Morgan Stanley analyst William Greene Tuesday went as far as to call Southwest an “oil play,” and complained that airlines’ fuel hedges cover a multitude of sins and may be an excuse for the airline to avoid cutting capacity. Greene wrote: “Considering that [Southwest’s] management recently suggested it may revisit its capacity plans and potentially raise growth suggests that management does not view its fuel hedge as a temporary comparative advantage but rather as a durable competitive advantage. Not addressing the company’s economic challenges today may lead to a more difficult adjustment in the future.”
The question, as always, is whether capacity cuts are what the industry needs. Greene believes they are. Still, late last week he presented several reasons why airlines would want to avoid any extensive cuts in capacity and “chase oil” instead. In his words:
(1) The network effect of a hub-and-spoke model deteriorates as capacity is cut
(2) Labor contracts, fleet planning, and aircraft/facility financing make large capacity cuts difficult to reverse in the short-term
(3) An habitual (if currently muted) focus on maintaining and gaining market share
(4) An inability to predict competitive responses
(5) Lack of visibility in airline revenue trends
(6) Uncertainty surrounding oil prices, a pullback could quickly make many routes profitabl
Employees who made significant concessions in union negotiations are going to be watching that bottom line very carefully — especially the pilots at Delta and Northwest. As Delta noted today, “Pilots at both companies will receive pay raises and an equity stake in the combined company.” That money has to come from somewhere.[/quote]

It will come from the pilots that are furloughed.....
cfii2007 is offline  
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
wannabepilot
Flight Schools and Training
34
07-07-2008 12:15 PM
AviatorPop
Hangar Talk
2
07-03-2008 02:31 PM
JiffyLube
Major
12
03-07-2008 04:27 PM
War Eagle 83
Mergers and Acquisitions
4
02-25-2008 06:46 AM
Sir James
Major
1
01-05-2006 07:59 PM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Thread Tools
Search this Thread
Your Privacy Choices