Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Military (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/military/)
-   -   Overflights (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/military/94503-overflights.html)

MartinBishop 04-14-2016 03:25 PM


Originally Posted by SayAlt (Post 2109534)
Ahhh, an isolationist. Good luck with that.

Uh no one is talking about isolationism :rolleyes:

MartinBishop 04-14-2016 03:26 PM


Originally Posted by Packrat (Post 2109538)
Every nation has the freedom to navigate the seas of the world outside of territorial waters. What do you think the whole Spratley Islands debate is about?

Naaw... if the Russian government had the most advanced warship in the world parked off the US coast we wouldn't think a thing about it. We definitely wouldn't consider it threatening or hostile. :rolleyes:

iceman49 04-14-2016 05:34 PM


Originally Posted by Packrat (Post 2109538)
Every nation has the freedom to navigate the seas of the world outside of territorial waters. What do you think the whole Spratley Islands debate is about?

The one I've always enjoyed is "due regard." :)

Packrat 04-14-2016 05:57 PM


Originally Posted by MartinBishop (Post 2109738)
Naaw... if the Russian government had the most advanced warship in the world parked off the US coast we wouldn't think a thing about it. We definitely wouldn't consider it threatening or hostile. :rolleyes:

You obviously have no idea what the Navy is all about. Perhaps you should TRY to educate yourself before you comment on such topics.

HuggyU2 04-14-2016 06:32 PM

Bottom line: irrespective of "whose airspace it is", the Russians do not respect us, nor our resolve to stand up to them. Not that I believe it warrants a shoot down... But Putin certainly knows how to make a statement... Especially after the Turkish embarrassment.

The two Russian pilots are yucking it up in their squadron bar and are not buying a single round. There is a gigantic 4' x 8' color glossy photo of the flyby picture plastered in their bar... in their Maintenance squadron,... in their Intel squadron.... and in the "I love me room" in the apartment that each pilot lives in.

They are laughing at us and calling us ****

I'd be doing the same thing if the role was reversed.

rickair7777 04-14-2016 07:22 PM


Originally Posted by MartinBishop (Post 2109738)
Naaw... if the Russian government had the most advanced warship in the world parked off the US coast we wouldn't think a thing about it. We definitely wouldn't consider it threatening or hostile. :rolleyes:


They actually do that, you just don't read about it in the media much. But we don't make aggressive simulated attacks when they visit. Not in this day and age. Fly-by look-see, perhaps.

rickair7777 04-14-2016 07:25 PM


Originally Posted by BDGERJMN (Post 2109458)
What AOR are you talking about? CENTCOM? PACOM? No chance, Paddles!

Where the batpoop crazy people are. The russians you can sort of assume aren't actually going to shoot you or kamikaze...you cannot in good conscience make that assumption about certain other potential adversaries.

rickair7777 04-14-2016 07:32 PM


Originally Posted by Otterbox (Post 2109267)
Nope, not really at all. This really isn't unexpected or unusual when you look at how our interactions have been with the Russians in recent history.

There was virtually no danger of those aircraft getting shot down by the ship. Foreign powers attempt to force overreactions from our crews all the time (aka charge the ships in an attempt to get it to shoot at them so the ship gets pulled from theater and were too ashamed politically to send a replacement). Is it annoying? Yes. Is it exciting? Yes but a lot of our training and qualifications these days goes into when to not shoot a guy, and these incidents were one of those times. Other countries do this to us all of the time because they know how restrained our reactions will be.

Makes good for CNN headlines though.

It was safer during the cold war, when everybody knew the game and the rules. More uncertainty today. The reaction is tailored to the adversary, so hopefully there's no confusion about whose airplane it is.

JamesNoBrakes 04-14-2016 09:44 PM


Originally Posted by jgcotter (Post 2109426)
Could have locked on with the ship's Phalanx or other defensive system, he'd see that in the cockpit, message sent, message received...

I'd be surprised if a CWIS wasn't locked on to it. I think THAT (painting inbounds) would probably be standard practice.

BDGERJMN 04-15-2016 02:36 AM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 2109863)
Where the batpoop crazy people are. The russians you can sort of assume aren't actually going to shoot you or kamikaze...you cannot in good conscience make that assumption about certain other potential adversaries.

Disagree completely. We're not operating in a culture or environment to shoot down anything in that part of the world. Our ROE and risk aversion mindset will force that interaction to be one where we take the first blow, as sad as that is. FAC/FIAC is a classic example of that.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:58 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands