Living Hand to Mouth - Ben Stein
02-06-2006, 12:50 PM
#1
APC co-founder
Thread Starter
Joined APC: Feb 2005
Position: B777
Posts: 5,853
Living Hand to Mouth - Ben Stein
Living Hand to Mouth -- and Barely Getting By
by Ben Stein
Monday, February 6, 2006
A word of warning: This article is not going to contain any stock suggestions or tips. This column is warning of a different sort -- about the U.S. economy and the problems it faces.
I can summarize the shape of the U.S. economy by telling an anecdote. One of my closest friends is a lovely 45-year-old woman whom I will call Vivian. She has a good job in real estate, a lovely rented apartment in a city in California, a sweet little car, and elegant clothing. She earns about $75,000 a year.
Not Thinking Ahead
A few days ago, I asked her if she had considered variable annuities, bought with a very sharp eye on fees, for her retirement portfolio (please see "Income That Lasts as Long as You Need It"). She looked shocked and asked, "What retirement portfolio? Do I look that old?"
"No," I answered. "You look shockingly youthful. But what are you doing about your retirement?"
"Well, nothing," she said. "I don't even have any money in my savings account and barely any in my checking account."
"Do you have a 401(k)? Or maybe a pension? Or IRAs?"
"No," she said defiantly.
"Well," I asked, "with all due respect, how are you going to provide for your retirement?"
"I don't know," she said.
"I think you should try to save maybe $500 a month starting right now in a very carefully chosen variable annuity, or else in a broad index fund I will help you choose," I told her.
"I can't," she said. "I don't have the money. Besides, $500 a month is nothing. It wouldn't amount to a thing. I might as well spend it at Nordstrom's."
I took out my calculator and punched some buttons. "I beg your pardon," said I, "but if you save $500 a month and earn an average of 8.5 percent on it for the next 20 years, you'll have $316,000 by the time you're 65. It's not a lot, but it's a lot more than nothing, which is what you have now."
She stared at me incredulously. "Do you think I'm going to work another 20 years?" she asked. "No way."
"Well, then what are you going to live on when you stop work?"
"Social Security," she answered.
"That won't kick in until you're 66 or 67," I said, "and it won't be more than a pittance by then."
"I'm leaving,' she said. "There's a sale at Nordstrom's. I have to buy something to distract myself from what you've been telling me."
Depression-Level Savings Rate
Vivian's story is the story of America writ small.
In a nation in the midst of a major economic boom, we're running a budget deficit of very roughly $400 billion. Most of that is being loaned to us by the Chinese and Japanese and by the world's major oil-producing nations.
At this point, foreigners run a trade surplus with the U.S. approximating $720 billion a year. That is, we're buying from the rest of the world about three-quarters of a trillion dollars more each year than we're selling to the rest of the world. The difference is made up by foreigners lending us money and acquiring American assets, especially Treasury bonds. At this point, America owes the rest of the world at least $3 trillion more than they owe us, and the sum is growing rapidly.
It's still a small fraction of total U.S. wealth of about $65 trillion, but the trend is extremely worrisome.
In a time of prosperity, American consumers' savings rate is in negative territory, roughly -1.5 percent of total consumer earnings -- the lowest it has been since the nadir of the Great Depression in 1933.
It gets worse. Total consumer spending last year was very roughly $8.5 trillion. Of this, about $700 billion came from home refinancing -- in other words, borrowing, supported by a residential real estate boom that seems to be coming to an end.
The long and short of it: We're only able to sustain the spending level we need to keep the economy at high employment by going deeply into debt to mortgage lenders, foreigners, and our children, the future taxpayers.
We, as a nation, are a lot like my pal, Vivian. We're living from paycheck to paycheck -- and barely getting by at that.
Boomers: Pitifully Unprepared for Retirement
But it gets even worse: Medicare is going to be bankrupt in about 11 years and maybe sooner. Its actuarially computed liabilities for the balance of the century, brought back to net present value, exceed the total wealth of the nation, by some calculations.
We are, in a way, already bankrupt just from Medicare.
Now, in the face of these extreme imbalances and uncertainties, you would expect Americans to be saving like crazy to prepare for the future and its risks.
But instead, we're going ever deeper into debt.
And the part that makes it especially relevant is this: The Baby Boomers are the single largest part of the population by generations. They're about 78 million men and women. They will need a staggering sum to maintain their lifestyles after retirement, especially with pension systems that promise defined benefits collapsing.
But the Baby Boom generation is pitifully unprepared for the future. The average savings for Baby Boom households is less than $50,000, not including their homes. Even including the equity in their homes, it's not much over $100,000. And roughly half of all boomer households have either little retirement savings or none.
Sounding a Financial Warning
Yes, we have a fairly buoyant stock market, corporate profits are extremely high, and Americans could save more. The average Chinese worker, with average wages roughly one-twentieth of the American wage (and maybe less), saves 40 percent of his or her pay to prepare for retirement. The average American saves less than zero.
This is a society that needs to wake up to the gravity of reality -- and very, very soon. Let this be a warning: We are, in every way, living on borrowed time.
by Ben Stein
Monday, February 6, 2006
A word of warning: This article is not going to contain any stock suggestions or tips. This column is warning of a different sort -- about the U.S. economy and the problems it faces.
I can summarize the shape of the U.S. economy by telling an anecdote. One of my closest friends is a lovely 45-year-old woman whom I will call Vivian. She has a good job in real estate, a lovely rented apartment in a city in California, a sweet little car, and elegant clothing. She earns about $75,000 a year.
Not Thinking Ahead
A few days ago, I asked her if she had considered variable annuities, bought with a very sharp eye on fees, for her retirement portfolio (please see "Income That Lasts as Long as You Need It"). She looked shocked and asked, "What retirement portfolio? Do I look that old?"
"No," I answered. "You look shockingly youthful. But what are you doing about your retirement?"
"Well, nothing," she said. "I don't even have any money in my savings account and barely any in my checking account."
"Do you have a 401(k)? Or maybe a pension? Or IRAs?"
"No," she said defiantly.
"Well," I asked, "with all due respect, how are you going to provide for your retirement?"
"I don't know," she said.
"I think you should try to save maybe $500 a month starting right now in a very carefully chosen variable annuity, or else in a broad index fund I will help you choose," I told her.
"I can't," she said. "I don't have the money. Besides, $500 a month is nothing. It wouldn't amount to a thing. I might as well spend it at Nordstrom's."
I took out my calculator and punched some buttons. "I beg your pardon," said I, "but if you save $500 a month and earn an average of 8.5 percent on it for the next 20 years, you'll have $316,000 by the time you're 65. It's not a lot, but it's a lot more than nothing, which is what you have now."
She stared at me incredulously. "Do you think I'm going to work another 20 years?" she asked. "No way."
"Well, then what are you going to live on when you stop work?"
"Social Security," she answered.
"That won't kick in until you're 66 or 67," I said, "and it won't be more than a pittance by then."
"I'm leaving,' she said. "There's a sale at Nordstrom's. I have to buy something to distract myself from what you've been telling me."
Depression-Level Savings Rate
Vivian's story is the story of America writ small.
In a nation in the midst of a major economic boom, we're running a budget deficit of very roughly $400 billion. Most of that is being loaned to us by the Chinese and Japanese and by the world's major oil-producing nations.
At this point, foreigners run a trade surplus with the U.S. approximating $720 billion a year. That is, we're buying from the rest of the world about three-quarters of a trillion dollars more each year than we're selling to the rest of the world. The difference is made up by foreigners lending us money and acquiring American assets, especially Treasury bonds. At this point, America owes the rest of the world at least $3 trillion more than they owe us, and the sum is growing rapidly.
It's still a small fraction of total U.S. wealth of about $65 trillion, but the trend is extremely worrisome.
In a time of prosperity, American consumers' savings rate is in negative territory, roughly -1.5 percent of total consumer earnings -- the lowest it has been since the nadir of the Great Depression in 1933.
It gets worse. Total consumer spending last year was very roughly $8.5 trillion. Of this, about $700 billion came from home refinancing -- in other words, borrowing, supported by a residential real estate boom that seems to be coming to an end.
The long and short of it: We're only able to sustain the spending level we need to keep the economy at high employment by going deeply into debt to mortgage lenders, foreigners, and our children, the future taxpayers.
We, as a nation, are a lot like my pal, Vivian. We're living from paycheck to paycheck -- and barely getting by at that.
Boomers: Pitifully Unprepared for Retirement
But it gets even worse: Medicare is going to be bankrupt in about 11 years and maybe sooner. Its actuarially computed liabilities for the balance of the century, brought back to net present value, exceed the total wealth of the nation, by some calculations.
We are, in a way, already bankrupt just from Medicare.
Now, in the face of these extreme imbalances and uncertainties, you would expect Americans to be saving like crazy to prepare for the future and its risks.
But instead, we're going ever deeper into debt.
And the part that makes it especially relevant is this: The Baby Boomers are the single largest part of the population by generations. They're about 78 million men and women. They will need a staggering sum to maintain their lifestyles after retirement, especially with pension systems that promise defined benefits collapsing.
But the Baby Boom generation is pitifully unprepared for the future. The average savings for Baby Boom households is less than $50,000, not including their homes. Even including the equity in their homes, it's not much over $100,000. And roughly half of all boomer households have either little retirement savings or none.
Sounding a Financial Warning
Yes, we have a fairly buoyant stock market, corporate profits are extremely high, and Americans could save more. The average Chinese worker, with average wages roughly one-twentieth of the American wage (and maybe less), saves 40 percent of his or her pay to prepare for retirement. The average American saves less than zero.
This is a society that needs to wake up to the gravity of reality -- and very, very soon. Let this be a warning: We are, in every way, living on borrowed time.
02-07-2006, 05:29 AM
#2
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Apr 2005
Position: 767ER capt
Posts: 1,190
Ben Stein, as always, hits the nail on the head. My brother, who is a mortgage banker in N.J., says he sees the same people every year- they refinance their house, taking out the equity to pay off their credit cards. EVERY YEAR!
I've told my teenage sons that while drugs are bad, I've seen more lives ruined by credit cards than by drugs.
I've told my teenage sons that while drugs are bad, I've seen more lives ruined by credit cards than by drugs.
02-07-2006, 06:07 AM
#3
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Sep 2005
Position: Any, usually behind the wing
Posts: 382
I also have a good friend who is a mortgage banker. He would talk of computer consultant married couples who made $300-400K/year-combined- when the tech times were good. With a little effort, they could've paid cash for a$ $250-$400,000 home (which BTW still buys a very nice home in this area). Instead, they're now laid off, up to their eyeballs in debt, and trying to refinance. They could be living in a beautiful home for the $2,000-$4,000 in annual property taxes; but they spent it all.
My brother, who is not a complete idiot with his money (possibly a partial) started his own company. He would tell me I'm "really hurting money wise". Then I would look at his vehicles and there would be a year-old loaded Suburban 4X4 and a brand-new Z71 crew cab 4X4 pickup. $60-70,000 in vehicles? Please don't tell me your hurting. I do sales just like him- drive 40,000-50,000 miles year- have a 2005 Taurus, purchased used from Hertz Car Sales. Why, because it is a disposable item for me to drive into the ground. Do I wish I drove something nicer, sure, but then I tell my self I saved 10-20 grand and I'm getting there at the same speed.
The local credit load here in the Research Triangle area is something like $10,000 per household in credit cards alone. It's just shocking.
My brother, who is not a complete idiot with his money (possibly a partial) started his own company. He would tell me I'm "really hurting money wise". Then I would look at his vehicles and there would be a year-old loaded Suburban 4X4 and a brand-new Z71 crew cab 4X4 pickup. $60-70,000 in vehicles? Please don't tell me your hurting. I do sales just like him- drive 40,000-50,000 miles year- have a 2005 Taurus, purchased used from Hertz Car Sales. Why, because it is a disposable item for me to drive into the ground. Do I wish I drove something nicer, sure, but then I tell my self I saved 10-20 grand and I'm getting there at the same speed.
The local credit load here in the Research Triangle area is something like $10,000 per household in credit cards alone. It's just shocking.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
