Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   Call The Media!!! Sully Broke Sterile!!!!! (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/40872-call-media-sully-broke-sterile.html)

ryguy 06-10-2009 01:45 PM


Originally Posted by snippercr (Post 626025)
Out of curiosity, how much do commercial pilots practice total thrust lost scenarios? While during private and commercial training, we did them all the time, but I imagine a archer or 172 handles a bit differently than a larger aircraft. I know much remains the same, but when would have been the last time they practiced them? I know when I went for my ME add on, I asked about total thrust lost and my instructor said it is not considered. When I went for my MEI, I asked if I should teach total thrust lost and was told same thing.

The answer is, we don't. I've never once done a complete power loss in an airliner nor have I ever practiced a ditching. It is one of those things that is so rare that your time is better spent working on things that are more likely to happen.

ovrtake92 06-10-2009 02:00 PM

Whats to practice with loss of all engines, If you dont know to point the nose down and look for the best place to land then you shouldnt be in the pointy end.
Here, Ill right the "Loss of Thrust All Engines-Training Manual"

1 MANAGE AIRSPEED
2 KEEP GREASY SIDE DOWN
3 DONT HIT STUFF!!!

TPROP4ever 06-10-2009 03:41 PM


Originally Posted by ovrtake92 (Post 626105)
Whats to practice with loss of all engines, If you dont know to point the nose down and look for the best place to land then you shouldnt be in the pointy end.
Here, Ill right the "Loss of Thrust All Engines-Training Manual"

1 MANAGE AIRSPEED
2 KEEP GREASY SIDE DOWN
3 DONT HIT STUFF!!!

lets add
4. if landing in a field watch out for the friggin cows...lol

Dougdrvr 06-10-2009 03:59 PM

Hit the softest, cheapest thing in the area
as slow as possible.....

ExperimentalAB 06-10-2009 04:02 PM

...and at night during a forced landing, turn on the landing light. If you don't like what you see, turn it back off!

I can't take credit for that quote, but it's good stuff...

Deez340 06-10-2009 08:50 PM


Originally Posted by Emb170man (Post 625532)
Pilot: Bird warnings from tower of little value - Yahoo! News



A cockpit voice recorder transcript released by the board showed Sullenberger and co-pilot Jeffrey Skiles were admiring the view of the Hudson River less than minute before their plane struck the geese and lost thrust in both engines.
"What a view of the Hudson today," Sullenberger remarked.
"Yeah," Skiles responded.


After all the ****storm from Colgan and such, it would probably come as a shock to all of America that their hero, the mighty Capt Sully, broke sterile cockpit also. Wow...I'm suprised that those 7 words didn't cause him kill everyone onboard!!!! Stupid media. I'm so sick of their witch hunt.

He was just remarking as to the good visibility surrounding his eventual landing site. Very apropos thing to discuss in a sterile cockpit.:D

So, am I to understand that you're as happy and comfortable with the CVR transcript and airmanship of the Colgan crew as you are with that of Sully's flight?! Night and day.

Emb170man 06-11-2009 04:31 AM


Originally Posted by Deez340 (Post 626333)
He was just remarking as to the good visibility surrounding his eventual landing site. Very apropos thing to discuss in a sterile cockpit.:D

So, am I to understand that you're as happy and comfortable with the CVR transcript and airmanship of the Colgan crew as you are with that of Sully's flight?! Night and day.


No I'm not saying that...but the media hype and craziness/outrage that they broke sterile cockpit...and that's why they crashed (I guess the stall had nothing to do with it) is redicilous. Sterile is broken thousands of times every day...not saying it should be...but it is. A little comment about something on the way in, a question about whether the other guy is gonna grab something to eat during the sit, or just the end of a conversation started at 12000ft...it happens on almost every flight I've been on either as a jumpseater (this includes mainline flights, as well as flights I've sat right seat on. The fact that I say, "man...its June...there's still snow on those mountains" and the Capt says " yup" at 9,000 does not spell the end of us. I basicly can sum up everything by saying

1. Aviation "Experts" should try getting in an airplane sometime
2. Media should report on something they know about (and aviation obviously isn't it)
3. Trying to increase ratings with the bull**** out there like asking folks who really don't have a clue whether they think regional airlines are safe...and then keep on digging until they get the answer they want (no) so they can have a great soundclip is biased journalism
4. Well...just screw the media

577nitro 06-11-2009 05:25 AM


Originally Posted by TPROP4ever (Post 626152)
lets add
4. if landing in a field watch out for the friggin cows...lol

Always land with/parallel the furrows not against.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:04 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands