Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   FAR 117 rule isn't solving the real problem (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/78884-far-117-rule-isnt-solving-real-problem.html)

atrdriver 12-23-2013 03:42 PM


Originally Posted by BoilerUP (Post 1545914)
I was that poor regional FO, once upon a time.

I spent 7 nights in September 2006 sleeping on a couch in a crewroom in PHL. I had a sleeping bag and pillow there for just that reason.

It was most certainly not ideal, but as a poor regional FO it was the best solution I had to balance my financial situation as a commuting probationary FO while ensuring I met my responsibility of starting a trip rested.

We all make decisions every day, and flying for a regional airline isn't slavery or even indentured servitude. Nobody is forcing somebody to take a redeye to save a few bucks, and let's be honest with ourselves, if pay went up $400/mo you and I both know a HUGE percentage of pilots would pocket that while continuing the actions they are already doing.

More pay doesn't make safer pilots.

I've had better sleep in a 737 jumpseat than in a crewroom. You're delusional and flat out incorrect.

DryMotorBoatin 12-23-2013 03:54 PM


Originally Posted by atrdriver (Post 1545919)
I've had better sleep in a 737 jumpseat than in a crewroom. You're delusional and flat out incorrect.

I thought he was pretty much spot on.

RV5M 12-23-2013 03:56 PM


Originally Posted by Sum Ting Wong (Post 1545878)
They are not underpaid. No one is forcing anyone to work for low wages. If a person chooses to make $16,000 a year as a Regional pilot, that is his/her choice. He/she can make more money working full time as a grocery store cashier.

There is simply an abundance of people that want to fly for a living.

Writing, acting, photography, baseball, flying....too many people enter these fields and only those at the very top can earn a decent living. Somehow this message doesn’t get through. The pay scale is similar to baseball; the people at the top do very well, and those one step down (AAA league or the Regionals) earn something feeble, and the rest never earn a dime and have to find another career.

If its about safety we should "pass the hat" for police and firemen. Most pilots are pilots for a reason… it's a life long dream job.

A school bus driver holds the future of 25-50 young children each with the potential to become President. Are we going to pay him/her 100,000$ a year?

Maybe, but I think the market price of a first year regional FO is probably more than minimum wage. There's another force at work here, and choice has nothing to do with it. I wonder if low senority FOs are subsidizing over paid regional captains to some degree.

BoilerUP 12-23-2013 03:56 PM


Originally Posted by atrdriver (Post 1545919)
I've had better sleep in a 737 jumpseat than in a crewroom. You're delusional and flat out incorrect.

The PHL shared crewroom was pretty darn quiet from 11-5:30am. I wouldn't call it a Ritz Carlton but I was always plenty rested for the start of my trip.

I'd surmise anybody that gets better sleep in a 737 jumpseat than a crewroom in the middle of the night wouldn't have any issues being rested after taking a redeye into their trip.

All that said, I'm curious to know how I'm "delusional" and "flat out incorrect".

Again, *my* experiences when *I* was a probationary RJ FO...

conquestdz 12-23-2013 04:48 PM

What is with the constant "overpaid regional captains are taking regional fo pay" I keep seeing in various threads? There are exactly 0 overpaid regional pilots currently working in the US. No full time regional captain should be making less than $120K and no regional FO should be making less than $60K. Regional FO pay sucks (I am one), and should improve, but the improvement should not come out of the captains check. We all are worth more.

kingairfun 12-23-2013 05:23 PM

The pay and QOL is directly dependent upon the contract and work rules each pilot group decides they can accept......

My previous experience included Comair in the very early 2000's..... I think I made $24k first year and mid to upper $30s-low $40's from year 2-5..... Coupled with a massive route structure and good regional work rules, I was able to make it work as a single guy in his mid 20's.... Was it ideal...no. But I made as much as a teacher, or a medical intern as a new pilot....

Unfortunately the whipsaw and even younger pilots willing to do it for less in hopes of growth and a quick upgrade, ruined what was good at Comair.( talking about CHQ here BTW).. When the pay and work rules weren't sufficient.....I quit


If the situation doesn't work, bust your a.ss and work on an escape route.. The pay/QOL is only going backwards.. Too many pussified pilots too afraid of the threat of unemployment. I'd like to see the constant barrage on regional wages end, but I just don't see an end in sight considering many regional guys are still in the infancy stage of their careers.

RV5M 12-23-2013 07:45 PM


Originally Posted by conquestdz (Post 1545965)
What is with the constant "overpaid regional captains are taking regional fo pay" I keep seeing in various threads? There are exactly 0 overpaid regional pilots currently working in the US. No full time regional captain should be making less than $120K and no regional FO should be making less than $60K. Regional FO pay sucks (I am one), and should improve, but the improvement should not come out of the captains check. We all are worth more.

$120k? Is that number based on anything, or just part of the "more" that everyone wants? Take a look at comparable jobs with similar training requirements and barriers to entry, they don't pay $120k.

Here are two salaries for jobs that require more knowledge, experience and training than pilots:

Senior Aerospace Engineer: US Median $93,969
Senior Programmer: US Median $86,494 (This job is hugely in demand!)

But a pilot should get $120k? I think senior pilots' corrupt notion of how much they should be paid plays a big part in how backward pilot compensation has become.

JamesNoBrakes 12-23-2013 07:47 PM

The FAA and government don't care about your quality of life or how much you make. They just want you to fly safe. This concern won't end in higher pay for pilots. If you want the industry to change you have to change it and stop waiting/hoping someone else will do something (alpa, FAA, congress, sky king, etc).

conquestdz 12-23-2013 08:25 PM


Originally Posted by RV5M (Post 1546063)
$120k? Is that number based on anything, or just part of the "more" that everyone wants? Take a look at comparable jobs with similar training requirements and barriers to entry, they don't pay $120k.

Here are two salaries for jobs that require more knowledge, experience and training than pilots:

Senior Aerospace Engineer: US Median $93,969
Senior Programmer: US Median $86,494 (This job is hugely in demand!)

But a pilot should get $120k? I think senior pilots' corrupt notion of how much they should be paid plays a big part in how backward pilot compensation has become.

What did those jobs earn 20 years ago? The top 1% earners keep getting richer and richer. That is an easy enough fact to verify. That money comes from somewhere, and that somewhere is lower wages and outsourcing. I am not just talking about the airline industry. The methods and business practices that are common now to accomplish this were probably criminal in the past, but through lobbying almost anything can be made legal with enough $$$. It is a ridiculously hard trend to fight. I did just pull those numbers out of thin air as an example, and I know they are not realistic in this world.
My main point however, was that we should not be looking to raise the pay of first officers at the regional level by reducing the pay of captains at the regional level. That is a shortsighted erosion of the career. Our piece of the mainline profit pie is so skinny that it takes a laser to slice it. Our contributions are worth a bigger slice.

742Dash 12-23-2013 08:55 PM


Originally Posted by Packrat (Post 1545898)
It is absolutely a pyramid scheme. Everyone thinks they're going to be a 747 International Captain and make huge bucks.

The truth of the matter is only a small fraction of pilots will ever make it to a Major airline, much less a whale left seat.

A lot of you are going to finish your career in the left seat of an RJ so you'd better sack up and stop voting for substandard contracts. And you'd better be willing to strike to get what you deserve.

And that worked so well for Comair.

I am sorry, but the simplistic "Follow Me Over the Cliff in the name of ALPA" crap is not what this industry needs.

What we need is unity, and that means that we have to stop eating our young, preying on our weak and washing our hands like Pontius Pilot.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:42 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands