Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Safety (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/safety/)
-   -   Earnhardt’s Citation Crash (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/safety/123532-earnhardtis-citation-crash.html)

UAL T38 Phlyer 08-15-2019 01:24 PM

Earnhardt’s Citation Crash
 
Everyone safe...jet burned to the ground. Went off the departure end.

https://abcnews.go.com/US/dale-earnh...HuXF24mHlFAip8

nfnsquared 08-15-2019 02:49 PM

landing halfway down a 4500' runway would do that...huge phail in airmanship if those reports are true.

Will be interested to get the final facts.

The crash is already included in the Elizabethton Airport Wikipedia link. Wow...

cgtpilot 08-16-2019 07:46 AM

Dale Jr Crash
 
Why do these famous guys always have the worst luck with jets? Or the worst pilots? He’s lucky to have gotten out alive.

captjns 08-16-2019 10:16 AM


Originally Posted by cgtpilot (Post 2871109)
Why do these famous guys always have the worst luck with jets? Or the worst pilots? He’s lucky to have gotten out alive.

Reads like your asking the question in a rhetorical way. Present your thesis after your comprehensive study.

nfnsquared 08-16-2019 11:08 AM

This guy did a pretty darn good job in the initial NTSB briefing:

https://www.pscp.tv/w/1dRKZmYPydVxB

TL/DR:

Firm landing, bounced twice, one gear collapsed. Apparently did not land long. So much for eye witness reports about landing halfway down the runway....

USMCFLYR 08-16-2019 11:44 AM


Originally Posted by nfnsquared (Post 2871243)
This guy did a pretty darn good job in the initial NTSB briefing:

https://www.pscp.tv/w/1dRKZmYPydVxB

TL/DR:

Firm landing, bounced twice, one gear collapsed. Apparently did not land long. So much for eye witness reports about landing halfway down the runway....

Maybe those eyewitnesses considering the beginning of the landing as starting once the airplane stopped bouncing down the runway. :confused:

rickair7777 08-16-2019 02:14 PM


Originally Posted by USMCFLYR (Post 2871271)
Maybe those eyewitnesses considering the beginning of the landing as starting once the airplane stopped bouncing down the runway. :confused:

Well that is when braking could begin.

navigatro 08-16-2019 02:22 PM


Originally Posted by cgtpilot (Post 2871109)
Why do these famous guys always have the worst luck with jets? Or the worst pilots? He’s lucky to have gotten out alive.


I know nothing about these pilots or this accident, and am not making any judgements.

That said, there are a lot of rich people who hire their friends or "friends of friends" as pilots rather than the most qualified.

Brillo 08-16-2019 02:23 PM

Did an investigation several years ago of one of our fighters that crashed near a lake with dozens of witnesses. Asked, “Was the jet on fire or smoking as it was coming down?”

Half of them “Oh yes! Big black smoke trail and lots of fire and noise!”

The other half “ Oh no! It just kind of came down with no smoke or fire or anything. Real quiet.”

SaintNick 08-17-2019 05:03 AM


Originally Posted by nfnsquared (Post 2871243)
This guy did a pretty darn good job in the initial NTSB briefing:

https://www.pscp.tv/w/1dRKZmYPydVxB

TL/DR:

Firm landing, bounced twice, one gear collapsed. Apparently did not land long. So much for eye witness reports about landing halfway down the runway....

Bouncing twice should have been a reason for a go around. Especially on a short runway. Bouncing on ones landing gear can
Make it collapse.

JamesNoBrakes 08-17-2019 07:01 AM


Originally Posted by SaintNick (Post 2871633)
Bouncing twice should have been a reason for a go around. Especially on a short runway. Bouncing on ones landing gear can
Make it collapse.

You can often get two-bounces for free! The third is usually going to cost you.

TiredSoul 08-17-2019 07:15 AM

What are the chances DE was at the controls?

rickair7777 08-17-2019 07:38 AM


Originally Posted by TiredSoul (Post 2871696)
What are the chances DE was at the controls?

Well if he was, he can't really complain about the outcome.

John Carr 08-17-2019 08:03 AM


Originally Posted by TiredSoul (Post 2871696)
What are the chances DE was at the controls?

Well that it was nuthin’ more than a lil’ rubbin’, and rubbin’s racen’!!!!!!!!

On the serious note because in APC land, people don’t often get jokes, it’s GOOD THAT EVERYONE MADE IT OUT OK.

Swedish Blender 08-17-2019 08:38 AM


Originally Posted by navigatro (Post 2871376)
That said, there are a lot of rich people who hire their friends or "friends of friends" as pilots rather than the most qualified.

There's a lot of truth in this statement. I was offered a job out of the blue for a NASCAR driver by a friend. I was qualified but after discussing the job with the driver, decided it wasn't my cup of tea.

Sadly he was killed a few years later in practice.

DocMcFly 08-17-2019 08:07 PM


Originally Posted by John Carr (Post 2871720)
Well that it was nuthin’ more than a lil’ rubbin’, and rubbin’s racen’!!!!!!!!

On the serious note because in APC land, people don’t often get jokes, it’s GOOD THAT EVERYONE MADE IT OUT OK.

Ahahahahaha 🤣🤣 Yes and Yes

TiredSoul 08-17-2019 09:34 PM

What I meant was a lot of these racing guys are into aviation.
Michael Schumacher (F1) flew helicopters.
Wouldn’t be unthinkable to give the famous guy some stick time once in a while. Maybe even land when the weather is nice.
I’m just curious about what appears to be a very clumsy accident for a “pro” crew.

Excargodog 08-17-2019 10:51 PM


Originally Posted by TiredSoul (Post 2872009)
What I meant was a lot of these racing guys are into aviation.
Michael Schumacher (F1) flew helicopters.
Wouldn’t be unthinkable to give the famous guy some stick time once in a while. Maybe even land when the weather is nice.
I’m just curious about what appears to be a very clumsy accident for a “pro” crew.

Yep. It happens....

https://forums.jetcareers.com/thread...ntions.183089/

UAL T38 Phlyer 08-18-2019 05:10 AM


Originally Posted by Excargodog (Post 2872014)

Excellent article, Excargo. Thanks. I was in TAC when that happened, but never got that kind of detailed info.

O’Malley was a well-liked and highly respected guy.

PerfInit 08-18-2019 08:15 AM

Interesting related data that I came across recently - most of the EMAS arrestments have been corporate (Part 91) turbine powered aircraft. Hmm... A common recurring theme is Unstabilized approaches, Lack of SOP discipline, “pride” getting in the way of Good ADM (reluctance to go-around) , and pilots not fully understanding landing performance data could all be contributing factors. 10kts fast on final = touchdown appx 1000ft further down the runway. Glad everyone survived, but this hull loss was 100% preventable IMHO. We can all learn from this ad hopefully not to repeat it.

Dougdrvr 08-19-2019 09:51 AM

In this video there is a white streak extending up and to the left of the nose. It shows up at the first 10 seconds and then again at :58 to 1:20. WTF is that?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_qCKuleUFQ

rickair7777 08-19-2019 10:11 AM


Originally Posted by Dougdrvr (Post 2872762)
In this video there is a white streak extending up and to the left of the nose. It shows up at the first 10 seconds and then again at :58 to 1:20. WTF is that?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_qCKuleUFQ

Some pressurized fluid leaking out. Could be HYD fluid or even fuel coming from further back. Maybe even water from a lav/galley?

Dougdrvr 08-19-2019 10:29 AM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 2872772)
Some pressurized fluid leaking out. Could be HYD fluid or even fuel coming from further back. Maybe even water from a lav/galley?

I'm wondering if it's an ice inspection light or turn off light reflecting in the smoke? Hard to believe one would see that in daylight? Also would mean there is still power on the aircraft.

rickair7777 08-19-2019 10:35 AM


Originally Posted by Dougdrvr (Post 2872782)
I'm wondering if it's an ice inspection light or turn off light reflecting in the smoke? Hard to believe one would see that in daylight? Also would mean there is still power on the aircraft.

I was thinking it might a trick of the light with the camera, but it kind of looks like fluid to me. Could also maybe be O2 from the cockpit crew supply.

captjns 08-19-2019 11:54 AM


Originally Posted by PerfInit (Post 2872113)
Interesting related data that I came across recently - most of the EMAS arrestments have been corporate (Part 91) turbine powered aircraft. Hmm... A common recurring theme is Unstabilized approaches, Lack of SOP discipline, “pride” getting in the way of Good ADM (reluctance to go-around) , and pilots not fully understanding landing performance data could all be contributing factors. 10kts fast on final = touchdown appx 1000ft further down the runway. Glad everyone survived, but this hull loss was 100% preventable IMHO. We can all learn from this ad hopefully not to repeat it.

Glad to know you have all the answers to the accident. I guess I can pass on the NTSB’s final report.:rolleyes:

USMCFLYR 08-19-2019 12:06 PM


Originally Posted by captjns (Post 2872842)
Glad to know you have all the answers to the accident. I guess I can pass on the NTSB’s final report.:rolleyes:

And you are reading much too much into his post.
I didn't get that out of his post at all.

I recommend that you don't pass on the NTSB report.

Just remember where you heard it first! :D

galaxy flyer 08-19-2019 12:28 PM

This might be where PerfInit is getting his data. Eight bizjet arrestments, seven air carrier arrestments. Hardly definitive. I’d guess the recurring theme is high energy unstable approaches by all operators.

https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-n...as-arrestments

rickair7777 08-19-2019 12:58 PM


Originally Posted by galaxy flyer (Post 2872875)
This might be where PerfInit is getting his data. Eight bizjet arrestments, seven air carrier arrestments. Hardly definitive. I’d guess the recurring theme is high energy unstable approaches by all operators.

https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-n...as-arrestments

Weeeelllll... what's the ratio of airline to bizjet flights in the US? I'd be surprised if it's as low as 10 to 1, might be more like 100 to 1.

Alibi, bizjets fly more into smaller fields with shorter runways.

galaxy flyer 08-19-2019 01:20 PM

Agreed on both of the above, for most part. With 14,000 bizjets in the US and the size of US NJ fleet, the 10:1 is far closer than 100:1. Also, those smaller airports usually don’t have EMAS, so we get headlines like Earnhardt.

The rolling 90-day monthly average is 380,000 bizjet operations, 12,700 a day.

https://aspm.faa.gov/apmd/sys/bjpdf/b-jet-201907.pdf

The first three arrestments were air carriers at JFK. How does a SAAB 340 overrun there?

rickair7777 08-19-2019 01:40 PM


Originally Posted by galaxy flyer (Post 2872917)
How does a SAAB 340 overrun there?

Yeah I saw that and was wondering too.

2StgTurbine 08-19-2019 01:53 PM


Originally Posted by galaxy flyer (Post 2872917)
How does a SAAB 340 overrun there?

My guess it departed off the side due to crosswind and/or braking action.

galaxy flyer 08-19-2019 02:00 PM


Originally Posted by 2StgTurbine (Post 2872931)
My guess it departed off the side due to crosswind and/or braking action.

They have EMAS surrounding the runway? I don’t think so.


Gf

NJA Capt 08-19-2019 02:56 PM


Originally Posted by galaxy flyer (Post 2872875)
Eight bizjet arrestments, seven air carrier arrestments. Hardly definitive. I’d guess the recurring theme is high energy unstable approaches by all operators.

I can think of 3 air carrier incidents where they swerved around the EMAS. One was Mike Pence's campaign plane 2016.

TiredSoul 08-19-2019 07:42 PM


Originally Posted by Dougdrvr (Post 2872762)
In this video there is a white streak extending up and to the left of the nose. It shows up at the first 10 seconds and then again at :58 to 1:20. WTF is that?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_qCKuleUFQ

Oxygen bottle over pressure disc is around that area on a Citation.
Maybe....
Would seem kind of odd it would stay such a narrow stream.
2015 airplane, LED ice light maybe?

hydrostream 08-19-2019 08:18 PM

Glare from the sun on the windscreen. You can see the other “Ray” on the road at 1:05-1:08.

Dougdrvr 08-20-2019 09:14 AM


Originally Posted by hydrostream (Post 2873128)
Glare from the sun on the windscreen. You can see the other “Ray” on the road at 1:05-1:08.

Oh yeah, I see that now. Think you're right.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:11 AM.


User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Website Copyright ©2000 - 2017 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands