Well, I now have my ATP after my trip to AZFTC.
Here are my big picture take aways.
1. The owner Rick genuinely cares about his business and clientele. The place is built for military fighter pilots who want to fill the square.
2. You cannot go there and expect to be awarded your ATP based upon your charm and good looks. You will have to put in the 6-9 hours of study prior to the course and then pay attention to what Rick is telling you. He has a very good feel for what the examiners will ask and he has a LOT of experience -- over 7k hours in light GA aircraft.
3. I felt the examiner delivered a thorough but fair ground eval, and a big picture check ride.
4. The days were longer than expected -- 10+ hours on Weds/Thurs and on Friday my ground eval began around 6:15am and lasted about 1-1.5 hours. The flight was a 3.1 and ended about 12:30pm. The 1st 2 days were (probably) long because I had heard a ground eval went very poorly a few weeks prior and Rick wanted to make sure that I both knew what I was talking about and he wanted to allay my fears. I'll take partial blame since I majorly stressed-out and got almost no sleep the night before the 1st class after hearing about the near-bust -- instead of taking a 1 hour lunch I went back to the 'q and took a 2 hour nap!
5. There were a few negatives; however, I didn't think any of them significantly detracted from the overall quality of the program. Rick's equipment is all airworthy, but it has its issues. I had an HSI that badly precessed which is something I've never had to deal with before. My mag compass and HSI would develop up to 30 degrees of heading difference in what felt like under 10 minutes, made it very challenging to intercept courses when I wasn't paying close attention to the mag. There were a couple of goofy gauge readings which we had to alibi to the DE prior to the flight but he took it in stride. In addition, Rick is a really nice guy but his information to story ratio is about 2:1. The overall class time could be cut down if he spent a little less time on the stories and more time on the material. Maybe that's just the concise fighter pilot in me, but especially on my first day when I knew I had a limited time of useful consciousness, I was very frustrated when we spent a large part of the morning talking about the business, the FAA, and other random stories.
6. If you want your ATP sooner is better than later. Beginning 1 August of next year it will be considerably more expensive and take a LOT longer to get your ATP. Businesses like AZFTC and AllATPs will no longer exist in the format in which they operate now.
7. If I had to do it all over knowing what I know now? I'd absolutely do it all over at AZFTC (without stressing before day of of class...).