Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Southwest (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/southwest/)
-   -   Adios Wright Ammendment (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/southwest/84440-adios-wright-ammendment.html)

itsokimapilot 10-12-2014 07:16 PM

Adios Wright Ammendment
 
Decades later, Wright Amendment lifted at Dallas Love Field | Business | Dallas Business...

http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lvpl9gSkZ71qkxjew.jpg

tsquare 10-13-2014 06:28 AM

.....and the unfair slot controlled monopoly begins.

Name User 10-13-2014 07:22 AM


Originally Posted by Laramie (Post 1745388)
Dear Dumbass,

We were forced out of "slot controlled" DFW the day we bought Airtran.

Enjoy your day.

Nobody wanted DFW. Soon SWA will be suing to build more gates at DAL, because it's "unfair".

Even you guys have to admit there is definitely some sort of backroom dealings going on.

ZapBrannigan 10-13-2014 07:43 AM

Who cares? Just fly the plane and let managers and bean counters manage. As long as your paycheck cashes and you have lots of time off to pursue some interest outside of aviation it really isn't worth anybody's time or worry.

tsquare 10-13-2014 09:25 AM


Originally Posted by Laramie (Post 1745388)
Dear Dumbass,

We were forced out of "slot controlled" DFW the day we bought Airtran.

Enjoy your day.


Ohhhhh reeeeeeeeally?

Rsv4lyfe 10-13-2014 10:28 AM


Originally Posted by tsquare (Post 1745357)
.....and the unfair slot controlled monopoly begins.

You had all the gates you wanted in DFW. :confused::rolleyes:

Typical DL pilot.

tsquare 10-13-2014 10:33 AM


Originally Posted by Rsv4lyfe (Post 1745522)
You had all the gates you wanted in DFW. :confused::rolleyes:

Typical DL pilot.


Yup.. But wait.... you got gates at DCA... and LGA... why shouldn't DAL be open also? SWA is terrified of competition. Absolutely terrified. And they should be.

Shenanigans.

shoelu 10-13-2014 06:44 PM


Originally Posted by tsquare (Post 1745357)
.....and the unfair slot controlled monopoly begins.

You can scream that Love is slot controlled as much as you like, but that does not make it true.

inline five 10-13-2014 07:50 PM


Originally Posted by shoelu (Post 1745744)
You can scream that Love is slot controlled as much as you like, but that does not make it true.

No gates, it's effectively out of reach. Semantics.

tsquare 10-13-2014 08:20 PM


Originally Posted by shoelu (Post 1745744)
You can scream that Love is slot controlled as much as you like, but that does not make it true.

The farce is strong with this one^^^^^^^^^:rolleyes:

Still doesn't change the fact though that SWA can't handle true competition. Virgin America??? pfffffft.

paxhauler85 10-13-2014 08:20 PM


Originally Posted by tsquare (Post 1745527)
Yup.. But wait.... you got gates at DCA... and LGA... why shouldn't DAL be open also? SWA is terrified of competition. Absolutely terrified. And they should be.

Shenanigans.

Good point T! You're absolutely right; they've gotten to where they are today with that running scared mentality.

tsquare 10-13-2014 08:26 PM


Originally Posted by paxhauler85 (Post 1745795)
Good point T! You're absolutely right; they've gotten to where they are today with that running scared mentality.

Yeah yeah yeah.. and we all declared bankruptcy and all that crap.:rolleyes: Nobody cares about that. It is irrelevant. They are worried now. If they weren't.. why has it been three years since SWAPA signed a contract? Where's the love? hmmmmmm?

Compete. If you're so good.

Oh... and FWIW... thanks for the 717s. You'll be seeing them again at DAL. ;) (Apologies to the Airtran guys)

80ktsClamp 10-13-2014 09:45 PM

Delta (DL) #2255 ? 13-Oct-2014 ? KATL - KDAL ? FlightAware

Seeing this does put a smile on my face. Anderson wasn't kidding!

shoelu 10-14-2014 08:54 AM


Originally Posted by 80ktsClamp (Post 1745817)
Delta (DL) #2255 ? 13-Oct-2014 ? KATL - KDAL ? FlightAware

Seeing this does put a smile on my face. Anderson wasn't kidding!

Yes, you can thank Southwest for that. I doubt you will be seeing it past January though.


Southwest Airlines Co. said Wednesday it has agreed to let Delta use one of its gates to operate Delta’s five daily flights to and from its home base of Atlanta. United Airlines Inc. will lend ticket counters and other operational space.

After that, Delta will have to persuade one of the three carriers with Love Field gates to continue making room for its Atlanta flights.

“We have let Delta know that we are willing to potentially accommodate them on a portion of a gate through Jan. 6, 2015, in order to avoid inconveniencing passengers booked on Delta flights from Love Field during that time,” Southwest vice president and general counsel Mark Shaw said Wednesday evening.

Delta to keep flying from Love Field ? at least for a few months more | Dallas Morning News

paxhauler85 10-14-2014 11:46 AM


Originally Posted by tsquare (Post 1745799)
Yeah yeah yeah.. and we all declared bankruptcy and all that crap.:rolleyes: Nobody cares about that. It is irrelevant. They are worried now. If they weren't.. why has it been three years since SWAPA signed a contract? Where's the love? hmmmmmm?

Compete. If you're so good.

Oh... and FWIW... thanks for the 717s. You'll be seeing them again at DAL. ;) (Apologies to the Airtran guys)

Convenient of you to mention SWA not being able to bend their employee groups over like Delta did you guys in bankruptcy. Doubt anyone there wishes they had that opportunity. That said, perhaps the SWA guys have their goals set a little higher than 4/8/3/3, or whatever pitiful raise the majority bit on at DL. There's plenty of "love" between the employees and management, but labor contracts with a billion+ dollar price tag don't come easy or quickly.

If your definition of love is jumping all over a mediocre contract TA, then I'd prefer not to have any. I think most non-Delta pilots would agree.

tsquare 10-14-2014 01:32 PM


Originally Posted by paxhauler85 (Post 1746151)
Convenient of you to mention SWA not being able to bend their employee groups over like Delta did you guys in bankruptcy. Doubt anyone there wishes they had that opportunity. That said, perhaps the SWA guys have their goals set a little higher than 4/8/3/3, or whatever pitiful raise the majority bit on at DL. There's plenty of "love" between the employees and management, but labor contracts with a billion+ dollar price tag don't come easy or quickly.

If your definition of love is jumping all over a mediocre contract TA, then I'd prefer not to have any. I think most non-Delta pilots would agree.

And how long have they been waiting for a contract? Every year, inflation however fortunately low.. eats into their earnings. But I'll betcha that 4/8/3/3 would be fine with them... Of course I could be wrong on that, but they have not ever to my knowledge had that kind of contract. Hopefully shoelu will chime in on that. Either way though, inflation still exists, and when the bubble starts to burst, it will get bigger. And then where will a contract that is stuck in limbo be getting you? 0/0/0/0/0/0/25/5/5 is worth a helluva lot less than 4/8/3/3... and start again. It's just math, but that seems to be mythical on these boards.

Oh, and haven't you heard? All ours are cost neutral.:rolleyes:

But this thread wasn't about that anyway. I really couldn't care less what they do on their contract as long as they raise some kind of bar. What this thread is about is their government blessed monopoly at one airport. I'm guessing that there will be a lawsuit involved at some point in time and access to other carriers that will really compete with them will be granted. But for now enjoy the Delta 717 service.

shoelu 10-14-2014 04:22 PM


Originally Posted by tsquare (Post 1746232)
And how long have they been waiting for a contract? Every year, inflation however fortunately low.. eats into their earnings. But I'll betcha that 4/8/3/3 would be fine with them... Of course I could be wrong on that, but they have not ever to my knowledge had that kind of contract. Hopefully shoelu will chime in on that. Either way though, inflation still exists, and when the bubble starts to burst, it will get bigger. And then where will a contract that is stuck in limbo be getting you? 0/0/0/0/0/0/25/5/5 is worth a helluva lot less than 4/8/3/3... and start again. It's just math, but that seems to be mythical on these boards.

Oh, and haven't you heard? All ours are cost neutral.:rolleyes:

But this thread wasn't about that anyway. I really couldn't care less what they do on their contract as long as they raise some kind of bar. What this thread is about is their government blessed monopoly at one airport. I'm guessing that there will be a lawsuit involved at some point in time and access to other carriers that will really compete with them will be granted. But for now enjoy the Delta 717 service.

I'd take 4/8/3/3 as long as it involved retro pay which has multiple past precedents. Of course we are not trying to dig our way out from a 42% pay cut, if we were I'm not sure that would have gotten my yes vote.

There very well may be a lawsuit at some point, but the 5 party agreement is very clear. There are no common use gates at Love, they are now and will continue to be spoken for. The city of Dallas can force other airlines to be accommodated by the current gate owners but only if those gates are not fully utilized which is identified as 5 turns or 10 flights a day. If those minimums are met no one can force the gate owners to share their gates.

Delta had every right to raise objections when they were not allowed gate space in the current situation. Although both United and VA have announced service that will fulfill the stipulations of full utilization, they are not currently offering that service which leaves room for Delta to use the gates they formally had access to. If all parties begin flying the schedules they have put forth in January, all gates will be "fully utilized" and Delta will no longer be accommodated.

tsquare 10-15-2014 07:23 AM


Originally Posted by shoelu (Post 1746355)
I'd take 4/8/3/3 as long as it involved retro pay which has multiple past precedents. Of course we are not trying to dig our way out from a 42% pay cut, if we were I'm not sure that would have gotten my yes vote.

There very well may be a lawsuit at some point, but the 5 party agreement is very clear. There are no common use gates at Love, they are now and will continue to be spoken for. The city of Dallas can force other airlines to be accommodated by the current gate owners but only if those gates are not fully utilized which is identified as 5 turns or 10 flights a day. If those minimums are met no one can force the gate owners to share their gates.

Delta had every right to raise objections when they were not allowed gate space in the current situation. Although both United and VA have announced service that will fulfill the stipulations of full utilization, they are not currently offering that service which leaves room for Delta to use the gates they formally had access to. If all parties begin flying the schedules they have put forth in January, all gates will be "fully utilized" and Delta will no longer be accommodated.

Thanks for the contract info, that is what I figured. You got to where you are by taking small regular bites of an apple, not by gorging yourself when there are two. (For which I congratulate your group on as it has been far more successful than swinging for the fence everything you come up for contracts.)

As to the second part of the post: So how then is DAL any different than LGA? You had no slot rights there, and convinced Schumer that it was in the best interest of the consumer for you to get them hence our mired down deal with USAir. IMHO, that set the precedence, and SWA should be forced to divest some of those gates in the interest of competition. Probably won't happen because for some strange reason you are still the industry darlings, but it is a clear double standard. I'll betcha we will still retain those 5 flights/day after the dust settles, but any more will take a lot of work.

Boogie Nights 10-17-2014 08:47 PM

Record time
 
To go off topic.
Maybe southwest airlines is owed some reciprocity after having been forced to deal with the right amendment for 30+ years.
It was a bid to put them out of business after all. Not sure why you Delta guys would be worried you have a completely different product. If you're looking for fight you should going to DFW or better yet go to Denver as United's on the ropes. If you did that though you'd really have to compete with Southwest.

Justdoinmyjob 10-17-2014 11:14 PM


Originally Posted by Boogie Nights (Post 1748558)
If you did that though you'd really have to compete with Southwest.

Are we not already really competing in ATL? :confused:

WHACKMASTER 10-18-2014 05:56 AM


Originally Posted by Boogie Nights (Post 1748558)
To go off topic.
Maybe southwest airlines is owed some reciprocity after having been forced to deal with the right amendment for 30+ years.
It was a bid to put them out of business after all. Not sure why you Delta guys would be worried you have a completely different product. If you're looking for fight you should going to DFW or better yet go to Denver as United's on the ropes. If you did that though you'd really have to compete with Southwest.

Their beef is that SWA has gotten and continues to get special treatment. I can't say I blame them for being perturbed.

Boogie Nights 10-18-2014 08:07 AM

Yes yes you are
 

Originally Posted by Justdoinmyjob (Post 1748604)
Are we not already really competing in ATL? :confused:

Assuming you area Delta guy SWA definitely underestimated the demand for their product in ATL and Delta is cleaning up. Delta IMHO also has the best product of any legacy. My only point is that it is beneath the Delta guys to have sour grapes about DAL.
Let SWA enjoy the passing of a law that has been a thorn in their side for 30 plus years

tsquare 10-18-2014 10:26 AM


Originally Posted by Boogie Nights (Post 1748558)
To go off topic.
Maybe southwest airlines is owed some reciprocity after having been forced to deal with the right amendment for 30+ years.
It was a bid to put them out of business after all. Not sure why you Delta guys would be worried you have a completely different product. If you're looking for fight you should going to DFW or better yet go to Denver as United's on the ropes. If you did that though you'd really have to compete with Southwest.

That's just a sad, sad attempt.....

tsquare 10-18-2014 10:28 AM


Originally Posted by Justdoinmyjob (Post 1748604)
Are we not already really competing in ATL? :confused:

We are... they aren't.;)

tsquare 10-18-2014 10:30 AM


Originally Posted by Boogie Nights (Post 1748709)
Assuming you area Delta guy SWA definitely underestimated the demand for their product in ATL and Delta is cleaning up. Delta IMHO also has the best product of any legacy. My only point is that it is beneath the Delta guys to have sour grapes about DAL.
Let SWA enjoy the passing of a law that has been a thorn in their side for 30 plus years

Dude that law is what allowed you to grow into what you are. Had it not been for that you would be on the scrap heap of airlines alongside ones too numerous to mention.

Rolf 10-18-2014 02:10 PM

T,
Was the law made to squeeze SWA or not? The law backfiring isn't SWA's problem. Enjoy the perch, the view is awesome.

itsokimapilot 10-18-2014 03:36 PM


Originally Posted by tsquare (Post 1748771)
Dude that law is what allowed you to grow into what you are. Had it not been for that you would be on the scrap heap of airlines alongside ones too numerous to mention.

Easy there, you're gonna hurt your neck putting your nose that high.

MatthewAMEL 10-18-2014 08:18 PM


Originally Posted by tsquare (Post 1748771)
Dude that law is what allowed you to grow into what you are. Had it not been for that you would be on the scrap heap of airlines alongside ones too numerous to mention.

I think you should brush up on your aviation history...

The Wright Amendment was passed AFTER Herb prevailed in the Supreme Court and got the right to continue operating out of DAL.

In no way did it help SWA.

tr4a 10-19-2014 05:53 AM


Originally Posted by tsquare (Post 1748771)
Dude that law is what allowed you to grow into what you are. Had it not been for that you would be on the scrap heap of airlines alongside ones too numerous to mention.

Wright Amendment - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

OscartheGrouch 10-19-2014 06:10 PM


Originally Posted by tsquare (Post 1748771)
Dude that law is what allowed you to grow into what you are. Had it not been for that you would be on the scrap heap of airlines alongside ones too numerous to mention.

TS,

Calm down dude or you will bust a vein. Just a concerned suggestion. SWA dodged and weaved and others faltered. We may have to deal with our own issues in due time.

The Oscar

Road Dawg 11-14-2014 07:18 PM

Oh... and FWIW... thanks for the 717s. You'll be seeing them again at DAL. (Apologies to the Airtran guys)
__________________
DAL pilots were selected because they will never strike under any circumstances. - Carl

Yeah, you wait till those lovely Longbeach Surprises have you in a belly flop, when you open you mouth and look you'll see the radome of a 717, that's how far up it will be. Those frames were mediocre at best. They were glad to get rid of them. One sat for weeks waiting on parts. Hello....but you are once again right enjoy the cookies.....

RD

IAHB756 11-14-2014 07:40 PM


Originally Posted by Boogie Nights (Post 1748558)
To go off topic.
Maybe southwest airlines is owed some reciprocity after having been forced to deal with the right amendment for 30+ years.
It was a bid to put them out of business after all. Not sure why you Delta guys would be worried you have a completely different product. If you're looking for fight you should going to DFW or better yet go to Denver as United's on the ropes. If you did that though you'd really have to compete with Southwest.

Wasn't aware that United was "on the ropes". Thanks tough guy....

FMI 11-15-2014 05:27 AM

...yawwwwnnn.
This horse has been beaten enough... back to staring at Boogie Nights avatar.

jmcke 12-11-2014 06:48 PM

Any plans for SWA to fly from KDAL to CUN

shoelu 12-11-2014 06:56 PM


Originally Posted by jmcke (Post 1781467)
Any plans for SWA to fly from KDAL to CUN

----No.----

4th Level 12-13-2014 12:32 AM


Originally Posted by jmcke (Post 1781467)
Any plans for SWA to fly from KDAL to CUN


Prohibited by the still very much in effect Wright Amendment.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:55 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands