![]() |
I've never done/teached nor heard of anyone who teaches this.
Nor would I teach it to a student with less than 50 hours in a multi |
Never Have...Never Will
Originally Posted by DWS1
(Post 658609)
Question for the masses: Is the use of asymmetrical thrust a valid technique for control about the vertical axis in a crosswind in any jet, large-light?
On landing....NEVER !! Directional control in a turbo-jet aircraft is maintaine with ailerons, rudder or a combination thereof. Just my two cents Mates....G'Day:) |
Used it all the time in a 1900 when landing on ice in anything over about 20-25 knots of x-wind component.
|
Rtfq
Originally Posted by aviatorhi
(Post 659501)
Used it all the time in a 1900 when landing on ice in anything over about 20-25 knots of x-wind component.
In a propeller driven aircraft, perhaps, depending on the type aircraft and airport/runway conditions. That technique was used in a large tail dragger, such as the DC-3. Hmmmmm:rolleyes: G'Day Mates |
Originally Posted by aviatorhi
(Post 659501)
Used it all the time in a 1900 when landing on ice in anything over about 20-25 knots of x-wind component.
If you aren't using the rudder, you are either increasing your yaw to the runway and/or not killing your drift ... depending on which engine (upwind or downwind) you pull. See my previous threads if you need more explaination. |
Originally Posted by KC10 FATboy
(Post 660144)
I've flown the 1900 ... still don't know why you guys are suggesting this is a safe technique.
If you aren't using the rudder, you are either increasing your yaw to the runway and/or not killing your drift ... depending on which engine (upwind or downwind) you pull. See my previous threads if you need more explaination. Also, regarding the 1900 not being a jet, my apologies, didn't notice the question was specifically asking for jets, just saw a lot of bickering back and forth with one side talking about how it works in practice and the other side saying how it doesn't work on paper. Ever landed on a contaminated paved or gravel runway with crosswind components exceeding 40 knots? The reason the technique is used is because it works, it's worked for decades and it will continue to work, day in and day out up here, we make due with the conditions and equipment we have. |
I had to do a few landings in the DC-3 in which asymmetrical thrust was required to maintain directional control....especially when loaded towards the aft CG limits and especially during the landing roll-out with the tailwheel on the ground.
There is nothing improper about using asymmetrical thrust for xwind landings, piston or jet. |
Originally Posted by Radials Rule
(Post 661415)
I had to do a few landings in the DC-3 in which asymmetrical thrust was required to maintain directional control....especially when loaded towards the aft CG limits and especially during the landing roll-out with the tailwheel on the ground.
There is nothing improper about using asymmetrical thrust for xwind landings, piston or jet. |
Some of the people here saying "no no no no no" over and over to asymmetrical thrust for landing would have no problem executing a single engine go around in their jets. Riddle me that one. :confused:
|
Asymmetric thrust is most commonly used in fairly lightly wingloaded aircraft as a technique to get a little more crosswind capability from an aircraft that has run out of rudder and can't land in a crab. It just adds a little directional control when there isn't enough rudder.
Some heavy jets can land in a crabbed or partially crabbed condition and this may even be preferable in a low friction situation. It also serves to increase the crosswind capability. I have never seen a jet flight manual recommend asymetric thrust as a landing practice, or a takeoff practice. Would it work? Sure, but they don't want you doing it. Just like they don't want you exceeding crosswind limits or landing on an icy runway with no effective braking. Most of us don't want that recorded on the data recorder or having to explain why we were experimenting with an unauthorized method. Most anyone can touchdown in any crosswind within reason, the tough part is what happens after touchdown, keeping control of direction after touchdown in a jet is a little different than a light twin and there is less margin in runway width, reverse and braking requirements. |
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:39 AM. |
Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands