Go Back  Airline Pilot Central Forums > Airline Pilot Forums > Union Talk
TWA Pilots vs. ALPA in DFR suit >

TWA Pilots vs. ALPA in DFR suit

Notices
Union Talk For macro-level discussion: legislation, national unions, organizing pilot groups, etc.
For airline-specific discussion, use relevant forum above.

TWA Pilots vs. ALPA in DFR suit

Old 07-18-2011, 05:12 PM
  #161  
Back on TDY
 
Carl Spackler's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Apr 2008
Position: 747-400 Captain
Posts: 12,487
Default

Originally Posted by sailingfun View Post
I suspect its just a rumor. The TWA pilot group waived the labor protections in their contract voluntarily. AMR said they would not conclude the purchase agreement if the TWA required seniority integration process stayed in place.
Originally Posted by eaglefly View Post
What's the goal of this suit ?

I don't see how the seniority issue can be altered at this point, so I'm assuming a monetary award from ALPA.

Even that seems like a real longshot.
Originally Posted by sailingfun View Post
I would be shocked if it went anywhere. The TWA pilots made the choice they made. I guess ALPA could have tried to force them to not agree with the demands of the AA pilots to complete the merger but then its highly likely TWA would have shutdown.
Ahhhh...memories.

Carl
Carl Spackler is offline  
Old 07-18-2011, 08:11 PM
  #162  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: May 2009
Posts: 474
Default

Interesting, thanks.
globalexpress is offline  
Old 07-21-2011, 06:47 AM
  #163  
New Hire
 
Joined APC: Jul 2011
Position: MD80
Posts: 9
Default

Originally Posted by globalexpress View Post
Where did you get the specific information about the behind the scenes TWA bankruptcy negotiations? Did the facts you mention come up in court or somewhere else? It has been a while since I have read TWA's 10Q's but I was pretty sure it was a money losing operation at the time all of this was going on, but I'll dig them up to verify. Anyway, if you have a link or a reference to the stuff you mention, that would be great. I would like to read about that in detail.

Global,

The direct answer...I lived it.
I also have friends/co-workers who were in management and friends/co-workers who were on the MEC side. The bankruptcy transcripts where AA outbid Icahn and Jay Alix/Boeing should be readily available.
You can search 10K's til you turn blue but even a mediocre accountant can make profits disappear. Every airline in this country hides their money. Take a look at American right now. Labor contracts in nego and they cry crocodile tears about how they're losing money and that's what the 10k shows...so it must be true right?
But every April they have no trouble finding a couple hundred million bucks to lay on the big boys at the crystal palace in the form of bonuses.

If you want to verify the veracity of my statements you can contact the one TWA pilot who sat on the BOD of TWA. Or you can wait until he finishes writing the book and read it for yourself. Compton retired to Florida with a tidy $4M exit bonus....you can give him a call and ask him.
All Nighter is offline  
Old 07-21-2011, 07:02 AM
  #164  
New Hire
 
Joined APC: Jul 2011
Position: MD80
Posts: 9
Default

Originally Posted by stuart716 View Post
Did the pilot group get to vote on the integration to American or did the mec approve it and tell everyone that its a done deal?

No. The TWA pilots did NOT get a vote. The TWA pilots had no voice whatsoever in the integration. The APA drafted and implemented the entire integration (known as Supplement CC) without any input or discussion with the TWA pilots or their MEC. That's why it's commonly referred to as a "Cram Down". Essentially, AA and APA crammed their methodology down the TWA pilots throats and said "too bad, that's the way it's going to be".

Less than 2 years later AA furloughed 15 year TWA Captains straight from the left seat to the street.

The laughable thing about all of it is if you talk to a junior AA F/O today most will tell you the TWA guys and Supp CC are responsible for ruining their careers. I'm still scratching my head and trying to figure that one out.

"Two great airlines - One great future" .....yeah right.
All Nighter is offline  
Old 07-21-2011, 03:59 PM
  #165  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: May 2009
Posts: 474
Default

Originally Posted by All Nighter View Post
Global,

The direct answer...I lived it.
I also have friends/co-workers who were in management and friends/co-workers who were on the MEC side. The bankruptcy transcripts where AA outbid Icahn and Jay Alix/Boeing should be readily available.
You can search 10K's til you turn blue but even a mediocre accountant can make profits disappear. Every airline in this country hides their money. Take a look at American right now. Labor contracts in nego and they cry crocodile tears about how they're losing money and that's what the 10k shows...so it must be true right?
But every April they have no trouble finding a couple hundred million bucks to lay on the big boys at the crystal palace in the form of bonuses.

If you want to verify the veracity of my statements you can contact the one TWA pilot who sat on the BOD of TWA. Or you can wait until he finishes writing the book and read it for yourself. Compton retired to Florida with a tidy $4M exit bonus....you can give him a call and ask him.
Actually, I was looking for something not as subjective....no offense.

If the bankruptcy transcripts illustrating your points are readily available, could you post a link please, specifically to the bidding you are referring to? They aren't readily available to me.

I don't agree with your comments about airlines "hiding" money. They are required to account for their revenue and expenses using GAAP rules. If you are aware and have proof of an airline "hiding" anything I am sure the SEC would love to have a conversation with you.

Unfortunately, I don't think I will be able to get the court transcripts. If anyone knows how to get them , please post.
globalexpress is offline  
Old 07-21-2011, 04:29 PM
  #166  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Coto Pilot's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Sep 2009
Posts: 645
Default

Global you haven't been in the industrty very long if you honestly believe companies, including or especially airlines don't manipulate accounting practices to reflect what they want. There is nothing illegal with most of it, accelerating expenses in one year, writing down assets etc make it very easy to claim poverty while business is booming. Just look at the press reporting today regarding earnings reports, some spin United's $500+ million profit as great news and others make it sound disappointing.
Coto Pilot is offline  
Old 07-21-2011, 10:07 PM
  #167  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: May 2009
Posts: 474
Default

Originally Posted by Coto Pilot View Post
Global you haven't been in the industrty very long if you honestly believe companies, including or especially airlines don't manipulate accounting practices to reflect what they want. There is nothing illegal with most of it, accelerating expenses in one year, writing down assets etc make it very easy to claim poverty while business is booming. Just look at the press reporting today regarding earnings reports, some spin United's $500+ million profit as great news and others make it sound disappointing.
Oh, I believe airlines can do exactly what you are describing. A business, for example, could accelerate depreciation of certain assets, which may make bottom line numbers look better for that reporting period. However, if you accelerate it now you lose that depreciation later- it catches up with you eventually.

What I don't believe, however, is that an airline can "hide" assets like cash, real property, etc. If they were and it wasn't accounted for, that would be illegal. That was the implication that All Nighter was making I believe, and I disagree with that.
globalexpress is offline  
Old 07-22-2011, 08:46 AM
  #168  
New Hire
 
Joined APC: Jul 2011
Position: MD80
Posts: 9
Default

Originally Posted by globalexpress View Post
Actually, I was looking for something not as subjective....no offense.

If the bankruptcy transcripts illustrating your points are readily available, could you post a link please, specifically to the bidding you are referring to? They aren't readily available to me.

I don't agree with your comments about airlines "hiding" money. They are required to account for their revenue and expenses using GAAP rules. If you are aware and have proof of an airline "hiding" anything I am sure the SEC would love to have a conversation with you.

Unfortunately, I don't think I will be able to get the court transcripts. If anyone knows how to get them , please post.
Global,

No offense taken. The BK transcripts are available but I'll have to do some digging in my archives and perhaps contact a couple of the TWA pilots directly involved in the whole affair at the time to get a reference to them. They're a matter of public record and they're out there somewhere.

It's America...you're entitled to disagree. However, if you think every large company out there isn't able to legally hide money by taking advantage of the loopholes in GAAP and the tax code you're severely deluded. There are myriad ways for even a half-wit accountant to legally take cash off the books, and the SEC has no interest in such legal shenanigans...only the illegal kind.

I can tell you this...any research you do will bring you right back around to exactly what I said happened. It's been 10 years so my recollection of a few of the minor complexities may be a little rusty but my account above is essentially accurate.

My point is: Saying that TWA would have been out of business anyway is misinformed and inaccurate. Would TWA have eventually gone away on their own? Maybe. But if that were the case why would AA invest a very large chunk of cash to buy a competitor that AA's room full of Harvard MBA's thought was going away anyway? They could have waited for the fire sale and bought the assets for pennies on the dollar with no labor integration headaches. AA has a history of buying competitors they can't eliminate any other way, and TWA was in a resurgence. TWA's "Focus City" strategy in San Juan was putting a serious dent in AA's large Puerto Rico operation and AA simply would not suffer that. The purchase of TWA as an on-going entity gave AA "largest airline in the world" status and eliminated a competitor. AA was also the largest operator of MD-80's in the world and TWA had an entire fleet of the newest MD-80's built. TWA also had a load of active and dormant route authorities that AA now owns. AA sold TWA's Worldspan ownership interest and made back nearly the entire cash outlay they originally paid for TWA. All in all, a great deal for AA....not so much for the TWA employees who were stapled and furloughed into a black hole.

And how does all this relate to the instant conversation?....ALPA left the TWA pilots to twist in the wind without fair representation exactly as the jury determined. The funny thing is, ALPA was courting the AA pilots and APA to return to the ALPA fold. Once the deal was done, APA looked at ALPO and said "if this is the way you represent your members we don't want anything to do with you". Ironic, wouldn't you say?
All Nighter is offline  
Old 07-22-2011, 06:15 PM
  #169  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: May 2009
Posts: 474
Default

Originally Posted by All Nighter View Post
Global,

No offense taken. The BK transcripts are available but I'll have to do some digging in my archives and perhaps contact a couple of the TWA pilots directly involved in the whole affair at the time to get a reference to them. They're a matter of public record and they're out there somewhere.

It's America...you're entitled to disagree. However, if you think every large company out there isn't able to legally hide money by taking advantage of the loopholes in GAAP and the tax code you're severely deluded. There are myriad ways for even a half-wit accountant to legally take cash off the books, and the SEC has no interest in such legal shenanigans...only the illegal kind.
Yes, if you could find the transcripts to the court case, the actual testimony, that would be great. I have a paralegal buddy but he only sent me the stuff I had mostly already on that TWA court website. I'm not looking to nitpick your points about the sequence of events. I just want to read the case and the testimony.

Color me deluded. The shareholders own the corporation. The Board is supposed to be a steward of the corporation. If any member of the board and/or management took cash, property, whatever, "out of the company" illegally, then they are stealing from the shareholders. Period. Agree to disagree.

Now I did find TWA's 10K filings. I did see, for example, where TWA prepaid some obligations, but the prepayments were accounted for as a company asset. It is very easy to see and was a line item on their 10K. Also, TWA was losing significant amounts of money for the 3 years leading up to their last filed 10K, at a time when other airlines were very profitable. Management might have been moving money from one column to another, but there is no way in my opinion they were cooking the books to the tune of those losses. Again, agree to disagree.

To answer your comment about why AA would want to get TWA in a prepackaged deal vs. waiting for bankruptcy and picking up the pieces, I would assume they would not want to risk loss of control of the deal, hence the pre-packaged agreement. And I read that ticket deal was costing TWA an estimated 100M - 150M annually. Now there is some stealing right there!

I am not disputing that ALPA did something wrong. They were found guilty by a jury- there's not much more to say about that. When will financial damages be determined?

Anyway, thanks for getting the transcripts if you can.
globalexpress is offline  
Old 07-26-2011, 07:03 AM
  #170  
AAmerican Way for AA Pay
 
B757200ER's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Oct 2005
Position: B-737 Pilot
Posts: 1,617
Talking

Originally Posted by All Nighter View Post
The laughable thing about all of it is if you talk to a junior AA F/O today most will tell you the TWA guys and Supp CC are responsible for ruining their careers. I'm still scratching my head and trying to figure that one out.

"Two great airlines - One great future" .....yeah right.
They have a very warped perspective, for sure. Instead of thanking their lucky stars for the TWA buyout and staple-job, which allowed them to continue working while TWA pilots hired prior to them were furloughed, they're complaining about their careers!

"Two Great Airlines, One great future---for THEM!"
B757200ER is offline  
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
GW258
Mergers and Acquisitions
270
09-30-2012 07:48 AM
Lbell911
Regional
23
04-22-2012 10:33 AM
usmc-sgt
Regional
44
03-11-2012 02:04 PM
SF340guy
Union Talk
92
06-12-2011 06:30 PM
Boogie Nights
Union Talk
22
04-14-2009 09:10 PM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Thread Tools
Search this Thread
Your Privacy Choices