ANC 747 vs SDF MD-11 for a commuter
#11
On Reserve
Thread Starter
Joined APC: Mar 2021
Posts: 24
When choosing 74-ANC versus MD-SDF you’re really choosing between a longer and a tougher commute with better trips versus an easier commute but with ‘much less than good’ trips.
Two leg commute sucks - period. Anchorage commute can suck even more because the flights are often full.
Is it doable? Absolutely but it can stressful. ..however, as long as you’re aware of the pitfalls you should be fine.
Personally I’d bid 747 ANC, put up with the commute for a year or so and then make a domicile change to SDF. (no extra training)
It also depends on your past experience - emirates, atlas, other long haul flying? You’ll miss the international aspect (covid bs will end at some point). Have you been flying primarily domestic trips? If you enjoyed it I’d pick MD. You’ll fly the same trips (but at night).
Good luck to ya no matter what you choose.
Two leg commute sucks - period. Anchorage commute can suck even more because the flights are often full.
Is it doable? Absolutely but it can stressful. ..however, as long as you’re aware of the pitfalls you should be fine.
Personally I’d bid 747 ANC, put up with the commute for a year or so and then make a domicile change to SDF. (no extra training)
It also depends on your past experience - emirates, atlas, other long haul flying? You’ll miss the international aspect (covid bs will end at some point). Have you been flying primarily domestic trips? If you enjoyed it I’d pick MD. You’ll fly the same trips (but at night).
Good luck to ya no matter what you choose.
What about relative seniority between the two? Which of the two choices would one rise in relative seniority faster to the point where one starts to have a little more control or options?
You also mention bidding to SDF after a year or so. How do ANC 74 trips compare to SDF 74 trips. Same, just easier commute?
#12
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Feb 2013
Posts: 1,339
Thanks for the input and perspective, whalesurfer. I appreciate the time you take to give us all some insight.
What about relative seniority between the two? Which of the two choices would one rise in relative seniority faster to the point where one starts to have a little more control or options?
You also mention bidding to SDF after a year or so. How do ANC 74 trips compare to SDF 74 trips. Same, just easier commute?
What about relative seniority between the two? Which of the two choices would one rise in relative seniority faster to the point where one starts to have a little more control or options?
You also mention bidding to SDF after a year or so. How do ANC 74 trips compare to SDF 74 trips. Same, just easier commute?
Good questions, I hope others will chime in because it’d be good for you all to hear other perspectives.
Initially your seniority would be about the same because being junior, at the very bottom, sucks no matter which domicile and fleet it is.
However, you’ll be moving up in seniority much quicker in Anchorage than you will in SDF. People don’t like to commute and when they can’t take it anymore they bid over somewhere closer to home - which then frees up more senior schedules to junior folks.
As far as the 747 SDF domicile - the truth is no one really knows what the trips will look like a month from now. This is a brand new domicile and the company is still trying to decide how to operate it. If I were to guesstimate, Anchorage trips are probably about 95% international. SDF has more domestic trips to choose from (ie, PHL, MIA, DFW on top of the ones ANC crews fly) BUT for now it looks like all of 747 SDF fleet expansion is happening on the international side too.
New hires of today have the advantage of being able to bid the airplane and domicile of their choice (if there are choices in the specific class). However, that’s also a disadvantage because folks worry about something which honestly isn’t that important because it’s temporary.
Think of it this way - no matter which fleet and domicile y’all get you will all end up with great careers here and will become financially ‘comfortable’ in no time.
To answer the original question:
- If quality- or ease of your commute is your # 1 priority - bid MD or anything else in Louisville [or Ontario] since you live in Texas.
- If quality of your trips matter more than your commute - bid 747 ANC and eventually bid over to Louisville. You won’t need any additional training and you’ll have the best of both worlds - the ability to fly international and domestic trips. ..and also a relatively ‘easy’ commute.
Good luck everyone. Those are good “problems” to have.
#13
Social Media retired.
Joined APC: May 2018
Posts: 775
Thanks for the input and perspective, whalesurfer. I appreciate the time you take to give us all some insight.
What about relative seniority between the two? Which of the two choices would one rise in relative seniority faster to the point where one starts to have a little more control or options?
You also mention bidding to SDF after a year or so. How do ANC 74 trips compare to SDF 74 trips. Same, just easier commute?
What about relative seniority between the two? Which of the two choices would one rise in relative seniority faster to the point where one starts to have a little more control or options?
You also mention bidding to SDF after a year or so. How do ANC 74 trips compare to SDF 74 trips. Same, just easier commute?
SDF 74 is about 100. The median FO is also a 2017 hire but the plug is an Aug 2019 hire.
SDF MD has just shy of 200. Median, again a 2017 hire. The bottom 50 were hired in 2020&2021. The top 40 are 2007 and earlier.
IMHO, MD will give you the quickest rise, followed by ANC. As covid issues ease up I can see more and more taking the whale in Sdf. Most certainly more than a year to transfer in.
The lines don’t look too much different between the 74 domiciles. Seems like a lot of the same flying just jumping on and off the circuits at different points. ANC has short (3day) trips to Asia, SDF has the same but to CGN or HNL. SDF has some turns and short domestic stuff but not much. On quick glance, the flying doesn’t seem all that different.
Hope that helps.
Last edited by FTv3; 04-29-2021 at 05:03 PM. Reason: Flow
#14
Social Media retired.
Joined APC: May 2018
Posts: 775
As far as the 747 SDF domicile - the truth is no one really knows what the trips will look like a month from now. This is a brand new domicile and the company is still trying to decide how to operate it. If I were to guesstimate, Anchorage trips are probably about 95% international. SDF has more domestic trips to choose from (ie, PHL, MIA, DFW on top of the ones ANC crews fly) BUT for now it looks like all of 747 SDF fleet expansion is happening on the international side too.=12pt.
change much for the next year or so but yeah, long term is up in the air.
#15
On Reserve
Thread Starter
Joined APC: Mar 2021
Posts: 24
Whalesurfer and FTv3, you guys (gender neutral of course) rock! Thanks for taking the time to share all the great info and the peek behind the curtains; I t’s absolutely invaluable for us outsiders.
Whalesurfer, I think you nailed it — it doesn’t matter what you end up with, it’s temporary and either way a great career.
Whalesurfer, I think you nailed it — it doesn’t matter what you end up with, it’s temporary and either way a great career.
#19
Its all good, hourly rates are the same
That being said, MD-180 Bunkjet pilots don't get to make fun of anybody, and Flying Crashpad pilots have been clowning other fleets (especially domestic ones) since time began. Besides, are your airplanes EPIC? No, no they are not.
That being said, MD-180 Bunkjet pilots don't get to make fun of anybody, and Flying Crashpad pilots have been clowning other fleets (especially domestic ones) since time began. Besides, are your airplanes EPIC? No, no they are not.
#20
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Mar 2018
Posts: 155
Its all good, hourly rates are the same
That being said, MD-180 Bunkjet pilots don't get to make fun of anybody, and Flying Crashpad pilots have been clowning other fleets (especially domestic ones) since time began. Besides, are your airplanes EPIC? No, no they are not.
That being said, MD-180 Bunkjet pilots don't get to make fun of anybody, and Flying Crashpad pilots have been clowning other fleets (especially domestic ones) since time began. Besides, are your airplanes EPIC? No, no they are not.
Sorry, I couldn’t resist....I’ll go back to my corner now
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post