View Single Post
Old 09-28-2011 | 10:47 AM
  #76699  
gloopy
Gets Weekends Off
Liked
25M+ Airline Miles
Line Holder
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 12,831
Likes: 172
From: window seat
Default

Originally Posted by poostain
Alright you super fantastic sexy scope gurus.

I am stuck on question 13 "the list" please break down how you numbered and why PLEASE!

Here is the list and it is not in a priority order, just as it was listed in the survey

Amount of flying done by DCI carriers (e.g. Compass, Comair, etc.)

Successorship/Merger with another carrier

Fragmentation/Transfer of Assets

Change of Control

Cabotage

Alter Ego

Subcontracting

Bankruptcy 1113 Protection

Foreign Ownership
Yeah talk about a Sophie's choice.

I was going to put subcontracting as number 1, because it is so general. But I didn't like leaving DCI anywhere but number 1. DCI is subcontracting, and it is, by far, our largest and most dammaging subcontracting. 40-50% of our block hours and a similar percentage of our pilot jobs.

Alter Ego is a holding company scope issue and we already have that, with only DCI being the outstanding issue to be resolved.

Bankruptcy protection is sort of a nebulous construct because you can't really ever have that, especially us as labor. I ranked that low only because why waste point weighting on something that would likely be thrown out in, well, bankrputcy?

Foreign Ownership and Cabotage are huge threats. But that must be handled at the legislative level and has little to do with our contract.

Successorship, Merger, Fragmentation and Change of Control are also important, but we already have about as much protection in those areas that any contract, especially any ALPA contract, can provide given the era of relative arbitration and the federal merger law.

So that's why IMO DCI is by far the biggest issue that is causing the most dammage that is most within our control. Its the issue that we can do the most about in C2012. Its the issue that our current book drops the ball on the most and that our next book can make the most progress on.

A close second would be the AK code share abuse, but there are at lease some supposed revenue sharing restrictions. Not so with DCI, where we get 100% of the revenue after paying 105-110 or so percent of the costs. And DCI is WAY, WAY, WAY bigger an outsourcing and a downward force cancer than AK.

YMMV.