LOL I see what you did there.

Anyway,

LOTR (all 3 duh)
Braveheart
Beaches
The Hangover (both, though 1 was better)
The Patriot
Old School (you almost got nunchucked)
The Big Chill (best writing...heck that's all it was)
Jackie Brown (actually as good as everyone wants to remember Pulp Fiction being)
The 6th Day
Wedding Crashers
With Honors

Honorable mentions:
District 9
Passion of the Christ
(both were absolutely great in their own way, and absolutely must sees, but I have no desire to watch either a second time)
The Departed
Bram Stoker's Dracula [1992] Just really well done in its own way. A new twist on an old movie that looked old in a new way. Or something.

Just F'ing with y'all about Beaches though.