Thanks to all for the info provided.
Planning on a couple of trips to the area. January, March, and May at a minimum.

I've heard some excellent feedback on Castle Rock -- nice homes, schools, proximity to Denver, etc. Areas North and West of Denver are also on the table if anyone has opinions in these areas. I'm definitely interested in Parker as well.

Around C-Springs, Black Forest, Palmer Lake, and Glen Eagle are of interest.
I'm an Academy grad so these areas could definitely be a factor.

The general Denver area sounds like it has a lot more overall selection to offer across the spectrum: homes, schools, church, golf, general recreation, entertainment.

At this point, the big picture question is what location has the best of everything? I know I have to do the legwork but I appreciate everyone's input to help narrow the search.