View Single Post
Old 02-19-2012 | 04:45 AM
  #115  
USMCFLYR's Avatar
USMCFLYR
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 13,843
Likes: 1
From: FAA 'Flight Check'
Default

Originally Posted by Boomer
I think we're getting stuck on the term "disease".

Some would consider addictions, shyness, shell shock, tourettes, and poverty to be diseases.

Others would consider a disease to be something like AIDS, Measles, Leprosy, or a burning case of the clap. If you look with a microscope you can see bacteria or a virus or something. If you get it on you, you can get infected. If you eradicate it from the body, you are cured.

I fall into the second group of people. When someone says alcoholism, smoking, kleptomania, or obesity are diseases, I find myself thinking "how can it be a disease when it's a behavior?" Do germs make you crave french fries? If gambling is a disease, than could laziness be a disease? Is child abuse a disease? Is aging a disease? Is that guy covered with tattoos from head to toe because he has a disease? How can someone who hasn't had a drink in 30 years still be sick today?

I blame the doctors for confusing things. If I break my leg, I have a medical condition. That doesn't make it a disease. If I cut myself intentionally or fear shoes, I have a mental condition. That doesn't make it a disease.

I have no doubt that alcoholism is a disorder, a condition, whatever; but when they classify it as a "disease" they're rubbing my paradigm the wrong way.

Of course I don't have any alcoholics or doctors in my family, so I guess I'm double ignorant.
Agree with many of the things that you are saying here Boomer - but if you could see that the brain chemistry (something you can see and track) is different in an addict and if you can see the brain and the body act differently when stimulated with a substance would it make a difference to you? The difference here that many may be getting hung up on is that this disease can be controlled at stated earlier and that control CAN BE in the hands of the person once they get help and started down that road to recovery (thus a person's behavior can play a bigger part).

USMCFLYR