Originally Posted by CALFO

Agreed,

It would be great to get away from this. However, there is such a divide in thinking over what did or did not happen in 2008 that I believe it merits discussion. If this divide is not bridged by the time an arbitrated ruling comes out we may find ourselves in USAir/AmWest debacle. I'd rather hash it out now than try to at the last minute.

Also, I like to hear the other side's argument. Some points are salient, others not so much. It is good to get the other perspective.