I'll agree the company probably overreached on this one (relative to what it takes to get 50%+, not relative to a 70% agreement). I definitely think the NC was correct to take this to the MEC, and the MEC to us, because it's probably close to acceptable, but might very well fall on the "no cigar" side.

Looks like Erskine had a better feel for this than Campbell. He knew to give us a little pat on the tushy after he was done with us. Campbell won't even sweet-talk, and that's kind of offensive.