Overall I like the letter, but this made me scratch my head about the meaning.

"We have not seen anything produced in these negotiations worthy of ratification."

I heard from my reps and the two "blast mails" that only the Compensation, Outsourcing and R & I" were still open. Admittedly these are big but the above statement implies the rest of the AIPs are also not acceptable, otherwise we have wasted all these years and are back at square one.

Tell me this is not what they mean, because if it is UAL Management has won the battle to split the pilots.