Your statement makes no sense at all. The job loss he is speaking of all came from well before the TA. The TA has been signed for just over 5 months. The main item that was a job giveback has not even been put into place at this point. The TA cost us jobs in some areas and those numbers are well quoted however it also generated jobs in other work rule areas that offset most of the loss. To claim the TA is why we have lost jobs since the merger is a bit stupid.