It made no difference that pinnacle was alpa. They asked the judge for what they wanted and got it. They asked the pilots for what they wanted and the pilots voted it in by 86% and now they are crying like a bunch of babies. How do you think that great contract is gonna look in a couple of years when the final fleet count is 80 900's and there are 450 captain downgrades as FO's and the remainder of the seniority list are gone. Alpa did nothing for pinnacle except take money from pilots. With an FO pay scale that caps out at $37/hour I'm betting 450 captains regret voting for that