Originally Posted by
TonyC
I'm not saying that the takeoff configuration is inherently unsafe. I believe it has advantages and disadvantages. It would be nice to have it as a selectable option based on the particuar circumstances of weather, weight, runway, and terrain considerations. As it is, we have no choice, we had no warning, and most pilots have only performed takeoffs with that configuration very rarely, if ever. Some Captains might even evaluate a takeoff with that configuration as one of those circumstances where he should, per FOM advice, perform the takeoff instead of the FO.
.
Tony ... all of the above considered ... I don't hesitate to use more flaps if necessary to load additional freight (it's still selectable in the PAT). I also don't hesitate to use NADP 1 for any reason that might be to my advantage. In my mind making those decisions are part of being a Captain. I'm sure you'll agree?