If the user base can let the site admins know specifically what works and what does not, perhaps they could incorporate that into a new look/feel.

From what I culled:

Content more important than beauty (may apply to wives/husbands too)

From my uneducated general aviation view, I could not discern much of a difference, content wise. I do have adblock installed, so that may help. I did not like having to scroll left/right to see the full pay tables.