Originally Posted by johnso29

I'd like to hear a reasonable, fact based argument that proves his claim. I've yet to see one from anyone. I've seen opinion and claims from one side, and I've seen factual numbers from the other.

I've never claimed ALPA to be perfect, and I've never claimed that they're infallible. ALPA has it's wrongs, but I still haven't been convinced that the alternative is anymore then a "might be" or "hope it's better" option.