Originally Posted by Really

I guess I don't speak plain enough! I thought the UAL proposal was FAIR!! Both before and after the SLI I thought UAL formula was going to be the way the list would be constructed!! Made more sense and had more logic!! Thats not really my point, just having a little debate with john about how the "mighty" UAL MEC will change things!! He still hasn't answered (surprise) how HE is going to hold NEW MEC accountable? He has had said how bad CAL MEC was and now we'll all win! I'm just asking how? I feel the reason is many guys don't like JP, particularly john! Yet, he was highly effective with profit sharing, bids, MOU's, and many of CAL's concern! That's what I truly think got under johns skin! There could be a thread on airplane color and john/staller/carol would turn it into JP conspiracy and that he must own the paint company!! As far as the SLI are you sure all of CAL's proposal was all tossed out? I think it was built using UALs formula but changed up, see Longeveity from 50% to 35% using some of CAL's argument. It's over I'm glad you think it's fair since I think this will be a strong airline with both groups!! Does it REALLY matter now who WON?