Originally Posted by
dalad
Also, our DB plan had already been "frozen". My final numbers on that was a lump sum of a little north of $580k, and a monthly annuity of around $5200. My PBGC at 65 will be more. My MPPP and other investments are now more than that $580k lump sum. So yes, I am actually now better off.
I based my numbers on the non frozen plan. My frozen numbers were about the same as you. I would not trade what I have now to go back to the DB plan.