I can't think of a base in the system that hasn't seen new pilots displaced out of at some point in the last 2 rounds of hiring. While its great to simply say "move to base" there is something to be said for being mobile and, while inheriting a commute, keping the family grounded and stable until you get some seniority and get a chance to figure things out. It also lets you make quick moves on any AE you want for pay/QOL without having to face another move.

Living in base is nice, but not all commutes are bad. Some people act like a 3-4 hour drive in "local" traffic is superior to half hourly flights. I think that's pushing the limits of the live in base propaganda. And not everyone can move. Fewer still can/will move to NYC or anywhere near. I'd consider moving right away if you faced a really tough particular commute. But for most its very, very doable. At least until you get some seniority and figure things out. When you're uber junior there isn't a seat in the system that will guarantee you won't get displaced. Going through a move just to end up commuting anyway is a pretty steep price for imagined stability.

Over half the pilots commute. Its very manageable, and far from the recreational choice some make it out to be, is in many cases a reality of the profession and industry.