It's discouraging when "our" "union" acolytes here insist negotiations must be "give and take" when the company is this profitable.
If we can't make gains ...straight gains without offsets... now, then we are in a "death spiral."

Why do we need to give up anything?

I'd rather take it to a grievance than roll over again with what is obviously not a home run. If it was a home run, there would be no need to release it with a slick "notepad" or worse...after the MEC vote.