I wasn't going to go there, but Wurmy said it well. I don't believe many in the pilot ranks would say he has been an advocate. Most of the deterioration in our relationship, quality of life and income have occurred during his tenure. He's perceived as one who talks much, and listens little.
Nonetheless, our former VP, JC, loved by all, but eventually left as he didn't see eye to eye with the exec leadership.

It won't matter who staffs the middle management ranks, the results will be the same