I'm not dodging anything, and I am very well informed on the issues at hand. However, by your theory(or at least those suggesting it), people are saying that denying jumpseaters is their way of solving the problem or getting even with them. This is not the way to solve the problem, and if getting "even" is your objective...that's just immature and childish.
Haha. Again you try and play it into something it isn't. It isn't about "getting even". It's closer to "actions have consequences".
There is no "getting even" because you can't equate 1 side losing their planes to another side not getting a ride.
Again, I don't fly for a regional and don't advocate any jumpseat war. But if an Envoy Captain doesn't feel like offering a ride to a pilot of an airline that will benefit, and played a roll in, his/her demise, that's their decision to make solely. Not for you, I or anyone else to sit on the sideline and say "you are childish".