Baxter, how can you possibly say the proposed new work rules were better? Across the board on reserve it was a weakening of contractual language. Allowing them to keep us on the road even longer than they do now with no tightening of the rather loose language already governing us. I've been on reserve here many many years and know what I'm talking about. You clearly don't. As for line holders, yeah I read that section as well. I didn't see many of the improvements in the proposed contract you said were better. Every cost is going up in life. So should labor costs as they share more of their ever increasing wealth with us. Republic isn't significantly worse than any of the others but it's most definitely no better. In the end, they're all rather $hitty in the right seat especially if you have any experience. And in the left seat they are a decent job. Better than what any of my friends are doing.