View Single Post
Old 11-24-2014 | 04:33 PM
  #85  
F15Cricket's Avatar
F15Cricket
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 536
Likes: 0
From: Right Seat 737, Front seat T-6
Default

Originally Posted by rickair7777
ADS-B has nothing to do with GA safety, it's about improved air traffic management which has an aspect of protecting airliners from GA (but not GA from themselves).

I agree that AoA certainly has potential for GA, but current GA flying techniques (and training & testing) evolved based on other instruments. Individual GA users who have the inclination can certainly acquire and learn to use AoA instrumentation. IMO (and only my opinion) applying it broadly across all GA would require big changes from the ground up, which would be opposed by various interested parties due to cost.

AoA is a getting a more direct answer to the question at hand, but you can still get the answer through other instruments...if I'm flying the proper profile I already know what AoA is going to tell me (except in icing). It would probably be easier for private pilots to scan just an AoA gauge and the runway in the base-to-final turn, but it's probably too politically challenging and costly to mandate AoA. But no reason individuals can't take advantage of it, as long as they commit to learning and using it correctly...otherwise it's just another dust collector, and possibly a distraction.
If your first statement is true, then, how many airliners have had mid-airs with GA aircraft? And, if ADS-B is for traffic flow, I am ignorant of why Mode 3/C is insufficient. Mandating ADS-B in all aircraft will not increase safety, yet mandating AOA would absolutely decrease the number of stall/spin accidents, from what I understand is the #1 killer of GA pilots.

And I agree that mandating AOA in airliners would probably not be required, since we fly in the meat of the heart of the envelope.

Actually, though, the FAA, as well as some of the GA organizations, from what I understand, are "highly encouraging" AOA gauges in GA aircraft, as they see the value in it. Again, if you have not flown with it, you probably think the wing stalls at a certain airspeed, but the wing cares not about airspeed ... It flies by AOA, so why shouldn't we?
Reply