In the No camp, too. If we give them this now, we might have to spend "negotiating capital" later to fix it.
Phrases like "unless the pilot establishes he has used due diligence" or "The Company agrees to meet and confer with the Association" can come back to bite us.
18 hours above gurarantee for 18 hours of work on top of our regular work schedule sounds fair to me. Or 10 hours above guarantee with a 2 day payprotected tripdrop.