Originally Posted by NERD

I totally disagree. I make it clear to the agent that I'll only give it up for a Nonrev and only if there are no jumpseaters. I don't give my seat up until just prior to door closing. I'm firm with them while trying to help a fellow employee. If the agent doesn't want to play by my rules I take my seat. This isn't that complicated, we have the backing of the contract to say no and hopefully the good judgement and common sense when to say yes. You seem to want to take the most obstinate stance at all times.