Making your decision based on what people Say here is a bad idea, IMO.
Make a list of the pros and cons for each. Where do you want to live? Company track record? Company outlook? Upgrade time? Flow thrus? Etc.
Don't chase the upgrade. Today's quick upgrade has a funny way of becoming tomorrow's dog ****. Don't listen to the negativity on here. Or you'll be miserable your whole career.
And for the record I chose Skywest over compass. Do I wish sometimes I hadn't? Yeah. But since neither are my career gigs I am not looking back!
(I also had pic time)
Bottom line: make the decision for yourself and not because of the opinion of others (especially here). Or you will never feel good about it!