We have a neighborhood "Rib Fest" every fall. For the last 3 years, the BGE has placed 1, 2, and 3. Last year, an electrically controlled smoker (don't remember the brand) took last place. The year before that, the Traeger was in last place. Personally I have never been able to screw up a meal with the BGE, it is truly GI proof. Does everything from bake pizza and bread, to slow cooking ribs, to grilling steaks to roasting veggies. At first the cost was a HUGE obstacle for me, but my neighbors (on both sides) and my brother way down in N.O. convinced me it was worth the investment. I succumbed and I've never regretted it.