C2012 - raises funded by cuts in PS
C2015 - see above

C2012 - SNB offered for additional large Rjs for DCI
C2015 - see above

C2012 - F/O bids LCA and has no recovery obligations
C2015 - F/O trips locked out from bidding for OE

C2012 - Vaunted JV language with EASK as measurement
C2015 - EASK changed to Block Hour since the company seems
unable to meet the percentage under EASK

Plus an extra nickel per diem, extra 15 minutes for vacation (no credit though) and an extra hour of TLV.

How could anyone vote yes for this.

I was on the fence for C2012 but ultimately voted no. Right now C2015 makes the last one look not so bad. An easy no vote.