Originally Posted by
PurpleTurtle
The East MC didn't even exist at the time of the supposed DFR violation, i.e. the trial. The East MC has never had a DFR to West pilots.
Silver is sure to put on a great show in her dicta, but even she will find it hard to name the East MC in her actual ruling. On the otherhand, maybe Wake would do it in a drop of the hat.

Yes, this confuses me too. Again, the
reality is that at merger snapshot date, like it or not, three separate groups existed. I can understand neutrality being required of the pre-merger unions and thus the surviving union and even buy the requirement for USAPA to not advocate anything other then the Nic (which may allow them to take no position at all just like APA), but each committee should be free to argue anything it so chooses (even at their own peril) considering the reality is that pre-merger there were three separate pilot groups with three distinct interests, separate equities and positions on the various aspects of SLI.