So what I'm hearing is that pilots on reserve want BOTH pay raises AND work rule improvements just for them. While lineholding pilots should ONLY get pay raises. Somehow pilots on reserve (many who have bid up to reserve for the extra payrate knowing what reserve was) are getting nothing out of the AIP while the lineholders get all the benefit?

Most pilots if given the choice between reserve not changing and taking an immediate 16% pay raise OR a great reserve system with no pay raises would overwhelmingly take the pay raises.

Voting no won't make reserve better in the near future. Reserve will still stink, and you'll be getting 16% less pay.